Warriors Wiki talk:Charart

=For Approval= Take it to the approval page

=Tweaked= Take it to the tweak page

=Discussion=

Leaving
As you know, I've been very inactive for the past month or two. It's summer break and I've honestly wanted to sit in and sleep all day because of all the stress school threw at me the last 3 days of school. I'm not one for big speeches, so I guess this is my final farewell. I will be checking in probably like.. maybe once a month or so, who knows, but I'm not interested in warriors anymore, and I've completely forgot that this site existed for a while.

Also about the mentor program, hopefully you guys can find someone to fill my place as I also  obviously  won't be active there either.

I hope everyone the best of wishes, Nice being able to talk to everyone once again! <3

13:42, June 8, 2016 (UTC)

I'm really sorry to see you go Bramble. You are a great user and I'll miss you very much. Good luck in wherever you go. 04:11, June 12, 2016 (UTC)

Rejoin
Hi guys! Id like to rejoin the project. When i left, i was a warrior so id prefer to be added back in as such. Since school is out and i have more freetime id like to dedicate more of my time to the wiki. I look forward to talking to you all again! 21:40, June 12, 2016 (UTC)

I would like to rejoin with my new account!
Hi, my name is breezy1235, and i want to join the project charart thing. I dont exactly know how to place a request, but I'll at least just ask to join. I have joined before with my other account, and I don't even know how I did that. Breezy1235 (talk) 19:45, June 26, 2016 (UTC)breezy1235

Of course! Read the guidelines for a refresher if you haven't already. Welcome to PCA! 02:52 Fri Jul 1

Join Request
I'd like to join this project. Seems fun.

Luavix (talk) 05:07, June 30, 2016 (UTC)

I'll add you in :) Check out the guidelines, and feel free to ask any lead if you have further questions. Welcome to PCA! 02:49 Fri Jul 1

May I join the CharArt project? User:Xaviapaw (talk) 09:17, July 10, 2016

Becoming an apprentice
hi, it's breezy1235 again and I'm wondering how to become an apprentice. Breezy1235 (talk) 07:40, July 6, 2016 (UTC)breezy1235

To be an apprentice you need to have finished a 50% of a charart --  21:09, July 6, 2016 (UTC)

Silvermask
So, in the comments of a charart I'm working on, Silvermask's deputy image, a topic came up challenging the fact that Silvermask get this image as he is only described as a dark tom. I figured the discussion would be better taken place here. So what does everyone else think? Should he get an image? I'm hoping yes because I don't want my charart to go to waste lol  -- 20:44, July 7, 2016 (UTC)

Comments? -- 22:58, July 7, 2016 (UTC)

I think he gets a gray one, but I'm usually wrong about this sort of thing. :P 1:19 Fri Jul 8

"dark" is a rather vague description. How do we know it's dark grey and not dark brown, or dark ginger, or even dark green? I don't think he should get an image for that. Also, Fox, please be patient. You asked for comments only two hours after posting the original question, which is honestly extremely impatient. We have obligations outside of the wiki, we can't always reply to things as soon as they pop up. If it had been three days, maybe, but not two hours.  14:30 Fri Jul 8 

Sunfish is given the description of "light-colored she-cat", and she has a charart. Although there is also an example of a cat with "dark" as their description (on the approval page) who does not have one, so... 18:47 Fri Jul 8

that was probably because she had an appearance in the section at the back of the book I think? 19:36, July 8, 2016 (UTC)

yeah, you're right, she did. (I have the book) With that in light, Silvermask should not get a charart imo. 3:22 Sat Jul 9

He probably shouldn't get one, as we don't want to assume what 'dark' is in his case

I'm not for or against anything here, but we already assume that 'tabby cats' get brown chararts. If we assume for one thing, we need to assume for something else that falls under the same category to be consistent. In my opinion, I don't like the whole assumption thing, but it was a vote in the past and there are default tabby chararts that exist now. 21:51 Sat Jul 9

I think there's something from Kate about the tabby thing, but that's not what this section is about anyways. Sunfish gets one because she was shown as a light-colored cat in the back of Crookedstar's Promise, and it's not quite the same thing.

Except it's pretty closely related. Both are assumptions about pattern and pelt. What's the difference about assuming for one and not the other? 01:57 Sun Jul 10

No, not really. This is about Silvermask, not the tabby thing. If you want to discuss it, use another section. I know I'll be against it, that's for sure, given that Kate has said to her that unmentioned tabbies are brown.

if we end up removing this image whiteclaw's will have to go as well. 02:05, July 10, 2016 (UTC)

I'm well aware this is about Silvermask, which is the whole reason why I'm bringing this up. I wouldn't bring this up if it had no correlation to the original topic. This is a discussion page, correct? I'm not going to start a new section cause it's been brought up many times before. All I'm saying is assumptions should be equal. Silvermask is a dark tom, and he's had an image since the dawn of time. Why go against the assumption now? I don't care if he gets an image or not, really, I just don't understand why we say some things are done one way and other things are done a different way. Personally, I don't think it warrants an image, but I'm discussing the topic, which is why it was posted here to begin with. 02:07 Sun Jul 10

We "assume" about eye color too, but I don't see anyone wanting to remove all of those images. The tabby thing is fine and I certainly don't see an issue with it; now, we could let people start picking their own color for tabbies, since they do come in a wide variety of colors. Personally, I don't really want to see perfectly good images go to waste over this, which was fine before now. =/

It's an absolute and utter assumpation that Silvermask is a dark gray tom with a gray stripe. We are against assuming things on this wiki, but suddenly it's okay to assume for Silvermask? He could be any color. He should not get a charart at all because it's assuming. 02:32, July 10, 2016 (UTC)

so we agreeing on this and remove those images or 19:41, July 16, 2016 (UTC)

I think at least Silvermask's image should be removed because the cite for him being dark-colored isn't valid anyway, and now the only description for him is a 'tom with a gray stripe on his face'. I don't see how you can make a charart for that without assuming that means his whole pelt is gray/gray tabby or something. It could easily be some other color. 18:53, July 20, 2016 (UTC)

I know it's assuming, but why was it put up for needed art anyway? Because now I've worked on a charart for about 2 weeks only for it to soon be deleted :/ --  17:53, July 21, 2016 (UTC)

Because the image was created when the wiki was a lot more lax on what did and didn't count as a description. We've changed a lot since that image was made (and tweaked/redone later on), so some images that were allowed back then, well, they aren't allowed now.

to be honest I really don't think it's that big of a deal. I say leave the image, I don't think it'll hurt anyone. How many people are going to rely on the accuracy of Silvermask's page anyways? 20:50 Sun Jul 24

Still I disagree. There are tons of images that don't have chararts now due to it not being valid and Silvermask should not be an exception. 21:07, July 24, 2016 (UTC)

rejoin..?
hesitant but whatever. So, I think ill rejoin for maybe a month or two until school starts. i have plenty of free time nowadays. Add me in as a warrior or whatever i was before 18:09, July 18, 2016 (UTC)

Sure, I'll add you back in, Bramble. :) 18:36, July 20, 2016 (UTC)

Join Request
Can I join? I've been trying to learn GIMP, too!

Neon Skylite (talk) 09:14, July 24, 2016 (UTC)

Sure welcome to PCA! Don't forget to check the Guidelines and our Apprentice Tutorials. Since your new, I'll add you in as a kit.Stealth f🔥re ❤Warriors Forever!❤  19:51, July 24, 2016 (UTC)