Warriors Wiki talk:Books/Discussion Archive 40

The Silent Thaw ~ Silver Nomination
+gallery, allegiances

CBV?

The Silent Thaw/Prologue - Silver Nomination
let’s get these stared fellas

CBV?

Shadowstar's Life/Cliffnotes - Gold Nomination
Credit to Sleekfang for a bit of touchups for the cliffnotes. -- 00:49, November 5, 2019 (UTC)

hold on here a second. I understand it is much different in PC, as many articles have been worked on by many people over a span of so many years, and the original silver nom becomes moot because the article is so drastically not even what it was. In PB, though, it's a lot different, and few people work on one article, and thus get all the credit for that as such. It's not technically disallowed, but I find it bad form that I, as the main silver nominator, am not the one to be putting this up. Whoever wrote the cliffnotes can do those up for gold, but it's set precedent by now for almost all of these ones that have passed for gold and are not FAs to be taken credit by their silver nominators, provided they are still here (and I am) unless they (for some reason or another) gave explicit permission for them to otherwise not be? The main article, gallery, allegiances, and characters are mine. The chapters need to be put up one by one for gold, and the cliffnotes can be put up by the person who wrote them.

I was unaware of that, my apologies. I did not know that only you could nominate them, so I'll leave this up to you. -- 01:04, November 5, 2019 (UTC)

It's alright, something to keep in mind for good form's sakes in the future. You can switch this out to just be the cliffnotes if you want to do such; and the subpages go up as singles. I'm currently holding on my gold nominations until I can bundle a batch past after TST's silver.

Done. -- 01:38, November 5, 2019 (UTC)

CBV?

The Apprentice's Quest/Cliffnotes - Silver Nomination
late night warrior edits lol 06:15, November 6, 2019 (UTC)

I think chapters 18+19 could be fleshed out a little more

reup 15:27, November 7, 2019 (UTC)

CBV?

Thunder Rising/Chapter 5 - Silver Nomination
EZ 07:24, November 6, 2019 (UTC)

CBV?