Warriors Wiki talk:Charart

=For Approval= Take it to the approval page

=Tweaked= Take it to the tweak page

=Discussion=

Hunters
aight so I'm well aware it's early but with Thunderstar's Echo comes the listing of hunters. new blank or no? I think we could use the already exisitng early settler blanks tbh, since they were made in the absence of warriors not yet existing, and they fufill pretty much the same exact roles as each other. (hunting obviously, patrolling, etc) what's your guys opinions? 21:40, April 11, 2017 (UTC)

I say use the early settler blanks, as many of the characters are the same anyway. This book seems to take place before the manga of MFV, and characters like Honey Pelt were given ES blanks because they were seen in that as adults. So I think that they get the Hunter rank, but get the ES blank

Seems to be a good idea to me; There isn't anything different that would warrant a blank change, so I agree with continuing to use the ES blanks.

New blanks for only one book don't seem like that wise of an idea, so we should just use the Early Settlers ^^Broken_Foot

They don't really seem much different from regular early settlers. I agree with everyone above, a new blank is unnecessary.

I agree. It seems like they just gave a name to a rank that's been around for a while, and they haven't really named until now.Stealth f🔥re ❤Warriors Forever!❤  02:00, April 13, 2017 (UTC)

Blue Whisker was called a ThunderClan warrior in Thunderstar's Echo, though. This poses a question: are they warriors now?

maybe...the structure of a clan and what a warrior is is basically set up now: they have leaders, deputies, medicine cats, those listed as hunters mentor cats, they hunt for the clan, fight if necessary, even have the rank of apprentice. I wouldn't be entirely opposed to a warrior blank, (and I know this is pc but) with a hunter and warrior listing. 19:59, April 14, 2017 (UTC)

Personally, I think we should use the warrior blanks. Yes, they don't have warrior names yet, but as said above the structure of the Clans is basically all formed now. 20:25, April 14, 2017 (UTC)

Yeah, we should use the warrior blanks for them. It seems fine to use them now

Onestar
Shouldn't he get an alt for the white markings mistake? 05:04, April 13, 2017 (UTC)

He has one, but I do believe we didn't know what rank he was when he was pictured with those markings? Plus, we don't usually use images for alts anyways. You're talking about Cats of the Clans, right?

We should use the alt leader with the white markingsBroken_Foot

But unless you have a cite for what rank he was pictured as in that image, we technically can't use that.

it talks about his life from warrior to leader, so he could be either in that picture, or even anything else. 06:52, April 13, 2017 (UTC)