Warriors Wiki talk:Charart/Accepted 182

Turtle Tail (Ki) - Approved
Demonic small blanks. And yes, before you ask, the entire side of the image is supposed to be white. This pattern isn't meant to be very visible from the front.

There's white waste above the right ear. :) 05:15, July 23, 2017 (UTC)

Re-uploaded. Also blurred a couple things.

Could you swap either the flank shading or the facial shading so that the light source is consistent?

I knew I messed something up with this. I'll fix the head shading in the morning... this is the one source that still confuses me, even after almost six years of being a lead. =/

If you plan to swap the head shading then the shading on that -> leg also needs to be swapped (dw I get confused too xd)

could you maybe define/darken the shading depth :] love her new pattern hh (her old one is still the best) 20:27, July 23, 2017 (UTC)

Re-uploaded. Her original pattern was the best, hands down. But noooo, that stupid tortie vote happened. =/ I will forever be bitter about it, and there ain't anything anyone can say that will make me believe otherwise.

I might be wrong -- light sources really aren't my thing -- but I still think that the head shading should swapped to be consistent with the source shown on the rest of the image. 13:07, July 24, 2017 (UTC)

I get that you're upset about the tortie vote, but with this new citation this pattern would've happened anyway :/ 13:31, 7/24/2017

The tortie vote happened ... you are allowed to be bitter, but I do not believe protesting like that gets us anywhere. Can you smooth out the shading? 23:35, July 25, 2017 (UTC)

Icy, that was unnecessary. You already told me about it on Skype, and bringing it here was uncalled for. We already discussed this and it feels like you're trying to start an argument with me. I'll fix the shading in the morning.

I think your head shading contradicts the light source.

Ivy already said that; I haven't reuploaded yet with the fixed source.

Oh, sorry :P Should we even be able to see the tail? Her tail is stumpy, and with the position the blank is in, the kit's tail wouldn't be able to reach that far around. Stumpytail's kit image doesn't show the tail.

It actually was not unnecessary, I have the right to respond to a comment on the talk page. It is not an argument with you, and therefore I will not be continuing it. Responding to Danny's comment, I actually think you would be able to see the tail on this image. Stumpytail's tail seems a tad shorter compared to Turtle Tail, but I actually will double check with the file. 01:18, July 27, 2017 (UTC)

Oh, actually, their tail length is indeed the same, Turtle Tail's actually is a bit longer. So yes, the tail would need to be removed / not seen. 01:19, July 27, 2017 (UTC)

Re-uploaded. I'm sorry, but I really don't agree with removing the entire tail. Stumpytail is a different cat, and just because one has the entire tail removed, doesn't quite mean that I have to remove mine as well. We can't see the backside of the cat, and this pose is confusing enough. I also asked Winter, and she agrees with keeping the tail, so that makes two and two. I'm going to keep it how it is for now, until I get a few other comments. I'd rather not remove it and then get told to readd it because someone wanted to nominate it later on down the road.

The shading on the front legs looks,, idk how to describe it. Blotchy/leaking, I guess?

Re-uploaded. Weird. Doesn't look like that on the laptop.

CBA?

Approved.

Speckletail (Alt Q) - Approved
All colors except the stripes obviously are from her regular queen. 15:57 Tue Jul 25

well i mean technically if you do it like this, she should have black stripes on her normal image and she shouldn't get an alt then 16:00, 7/25/2017

Reuploaded I just didn't know if I would have been required to keep the same base. This looks better anyways and not as...pastel vomit-y (for lack of a better way to descibe it) with a duller toned base. 16:05 Tue Jul 25

Can you add some shading to the -> ear? It looks flat rn

Winter, this would be an alt regardless. It was outright said that Speckletail being said to have black stripes was a mistake, so I think Sunjaw can use whatever color base she sees fit for this, even if it's the colors from the regular queen.

base colour shoukd probably be a bit paler or more golden but idk might renominate the other images 05:56, July 26, 2017 (UTC)

Reuploaded I really want to make this pale silver but that might be too far /: 15:51 Wed Jul 26

Honestly i wouldnt be against it, since mostly all cats with black stripes are either gray or silver 19:43, 7/26/2017

there's nothing that says she isn't golden, this is only about the markings. realism has nothing to do with it, regardless if thats how it works irl. 19:46, July 26, 2017 (UTC)

Maybe add some shading to the muzzle a bit and define the shading on the tail? C o s m o s n e s s 🐾 #cat lady 22:01, July 26, 2017 (UTC)

Reuploaded I swear this is the last color change I'm doing, I'm finally happy with it being pale silver lol 01:58 Thu Jul 27

again I'm going to ask, why is she silver? nothing says she was called that. 09:15, July 28, 2017 (UTC)

Because black markings usually mean silver, sun can pick any base color really. Rainbowmistake (talk) 17:21, July 28, 2017 (UTC)chat

Reuploaded Platinum blonde = perfect middle ground. Still technically silverish, still technically golden. Also redid the shading cause it was bothering me. 17:35 Fri Jul 28

warriors isnt real life, like i said realism has nothing to do with these. she has a cited base colour. the only difference is she has black markings, otherwise we might as well just make unspecified tabbies any colour we want then. :/

(this colour is fine btw sun that above isnt aimed at u) 17:48, July 28, 2017 (UTC)

Can you define the shading on the closest front leg??

Reuploaded That's as much as I'm doing it. 19:18 Mon Jul 31

CBA?

Approved.