Warriors Wiki talk:Charart/Tweak Nominations

TWEAK AND REDO NOMINATIONS ARE CURRENTLY:
 *  OPEN - Nominations can be posted. 
 * CLOSED - Nominations cannot be posted, barring the ones already on this page.

Before editing this page, make sure you are clear on the guidelines for editing it.

=Nominations= If you wish to nominate an image, you link the image (like so - ) underneath the appropriate subheading, and list the reason(s) you wish it to be redone/tweaked. Project members with the ranking of warrior or above can vote, and only five votes are necessary for the vote to pass or fail. If you have the ability to archive, make sure that at least a day has passed after it has a consensus before archiving.

Tallstar (Leader) ~ Tweak Nomination
File:Tallstar.leader.png Need to remove the back < paw's white, according to official artwork. 23:11, 10/18/2019


 * Deputy has master pattern, and that only has 3 white paws. -- 23:13, October 18, 2019 (UTC)
 * Like I said on the approval page. Deputy is the master pattern yes, but you cannot see the other paw. Plus the rogue image above yours has all four paws. Also the leader image has all white paws 23:16, 10/18/2019
 * changed it to say correct one 23:27, 10/18/2019
 * Changing vote. Yeah, I'd accidentally forgot to mention that one leg should have stayed black per his official artwork. -- 23:31, October 18, 2019 (UTC)
 * I think this nomination is actually incorrect. The amount of black that he has on his paws vary depending on what artwork you're looking at. Cats of the Clans, The Ultimate Guide, and Tallstar's Revenge depicts him with four black paws. Three in the last screenshot, since you can't see his other paw from that vantage point... but a quick glance at the rest of the graphic novel does appear to show Tallstar with four black paws. So, if anything, we should be honoring the more frequent mentions over what's being written in the books. We do often go with what's more frequently mentioned, so given that this was nominated and redone to match his drawn visuals, we should also be doing that here. ​​​​​
 * we added his white tail tip despite it not being in the official art. Why then not also give him white paws? 21:30, October 21, 2019 (UTC)
 * i just think it's a little silly to completely gloss over his official book description and just immediately say "oh the official artwork is what we will match". Why then, don't we do this for every cat that's been depicted with official artwork? Like Firestar etc 22:19, 10/21/2019
 * perhaps this would be better off on the PC discussions page instead of a tweak nom, until a decision is reached? personally, I don’t have much of an opinion of what we should be following here, seeing as the cites for his paws also come form TR.
 * Winter, it's not silly. =/ We decided to match his pictures, therefore we cannot and should not just disregard parts of it. A discussion or not, that is what the nomination was for. We can't just decide afterwards to only include what we want. Either match it all or not, plain and simple. Re: Egg's comment: that probably shouldn't have been added either, since that again contradicts the artwork we voted to match. Also, Max, this should be a PCA discussion since it has to do with the chararts. Perhaps on the talk page, sure, but it definitely belongs within this project.​​​​​
 * I understand that. I know he has pictures. Weren't the field guides at one point completely ruled as "non-canon"? 21:49, 10/23/2019
 * No, they never were non-canon. We never enforced matching the artwork. This set in particular, along with Tawnypelt, were nominated to match consistent artwork over various pieces of media. That is what we agreed up, to match that. Those images were created by Wayne and whichever other artists were involved and published as official Warriors content. Therefore, it is not non-canon and we should be using them in cases where things are consistent. Firestar's isn't consistent, and vary depending on what you're looking at. ​​​​​
 * is anything happening on this? we really should work out what to do and not let this and other's artwork just sit up and take space on both the tweak page and the reservation table 13:18, 10/28/2019
 * I believe the nomination should be changed to remove the white paws and tail tip (including the images which have them) as that would be contradicting his official artwork. -- 22:50, October 28, 2019 (UTC)
 * we should match his official art, as we voted to do. 23:08, October 28, 2019 (UTC)
 * do with this whatever ig 21:10, 10/30/2019
 * Voting yes to remove the white paws and tail-tip as they contradict his official artwork. This goes for images that were previously approved and those currently on the tweak page. Honestly, just voting to get this thing moving on so we can focus on other things. 00:47, October 31, 2019 (UTC)
 * I just don't see why we should disregard his written description. I can't support this nomination, but others are free to disagree. 17:04, October 31, 2019 (UTC)
 * agreeing with Vec

Dovewing (W, L) - Tweak Nomination
File:Dovewing.warrior.png File:Dovewing.loner.png Need torn ear. If I'm missing any images, please let me know! I believe Spooky will want the warrior. -- 23:48, October 28, 2019 (UTC)
 * yeah, these. I'll just take both, I have echo's file too
 * 05:19, October 29, 2019 (UTC)
 * 16:29, October 29, 2019 (UTC)
 * 00:47, October 31, 2019 (UTC)
 * 18:21, November 5, 2019 (UTC)
 * 18:21, November 5, 2019 (UTC)

Thriftear (K) - Tweak Nomination
File:Thriftear.kit.png Nothing much, but the highlights have always bothered me and I'd like to dull them a bit. 16:32, October 29, 2019 (UTC)
 * 16:35, October 29, 2019 (UTC)
 * -- 21:02, October 29, 2019 (UTC)
 * 00:47, October 31, 2019 (UTC)

Flywhisker (A) ~ Tweak nomination
File:Flywhisker.apprentice.png the stripes on this dont match and arent broken up enough, as well as the texture not being visble enough. it's pretty noticable when you compare them in the pixel box. 07:53, October 31, 2019 (UTC)
 * -- 17:26, October 31, 2019 (UTC)
 * 13:45, November 5, 2019 (UTC)
 * 18:21, November 5, 2019 (UTC)
 * 13:45, November 5, 2019 (UTC)
 * 18:21, November 5, 2019 (UTC)

Rockshade (Warrior) ~ Tweak Nomination
File:Rockshade.warrior.png I'd like to tweak it so his torn ear matches his official art, here the way it appears right now makes it look like he has a torn ear tip. I redid the warrior so I believe I get this. 18:21, November 5, 2019 (UTC)


 * -- 19:44, November 5, 2019 (UTC)
 * Good idea, Thunder. It's not mandatory though, just in case anyone else reading this thinks they need to match other things.

Robinwing (RC) (Set) - Redo Nomination
(app), (warrior), and (star) - Currently working on the StarClanner and even having Paleh's original warrior file, this design is very hard to replicate accurately - and trawling the archive shows that Paleh even stated the apprentice doesn't quite match what she had in mind for the pattern (aka matching to the original warrior). Moreso the point of this nomination is to keep the general concept of the pattern (smoke tortie/or dilute smoke tortie), but, make it, I guess, easier to apply to the three blanks and have it match across them better. I'd like to take these fellas on if this passes


 * 22:30, November 9, 2019 (UTC)

=Approved Tweaks= Once an image is under this heading, it may be reserved on the project main page and crossed out with a and a. The image may only be removed from this list when it is approved and archived.

All project leads are to keep track of the number of images on this list, including those that are crossed out. Should the number rise above 50, nominations will close and remain closed until the number of images on the list is down to 40.

When placing images onto this list, please also add if a user has reserved said image. Reservations will last for one week after the nomination is archived and placed into the correct archive, unless there are other matters that interfere with a user not being able to complete said images by the time their reservation expires (such as a comment that would usually require an additional nomination, like adding stripes or changing a pattern completely).

A tweaked image on this list can be redone with permission from a project lead. If a project lead wishes to redo an image on this list (such as a solid that is not part of a set), they must contact another lead for permission. If it is an overhaul of a set, another nomination must be posted into the correct section, and the voting process will begin again.

Tweaks

 * File:Berryheart.kit.png - recede white on arms to match set
 * File:Ambermoon.kit.png - minor fixes
 * File:Lionblaze.kit.png - make back a darker shade (Reserved to Patch until 12 November)
 * File:Lionblaze.warrior.png - make back a darker shade (Reserved to Patch until 12 November)

Redos

 * File:Morningflower.elder.png - artist's choice
 * File:Morningflower.queen.png - artist's choice (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Morningflower.apprentice.png - artist's choice
 * File:Robinwing (RC).star.png - placement issues on the face, patches too dark compared to other images
 * File:Poppyfrost.kit.png - pattern redo
 * File:Tigerstar (TPB).kit.png - pattern redo for mackerel, to match with Hawk and Bramble sets (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Tigerstar (TPB).df.png - pattern redo for mackerel, to match with Hawk and Bramble sets (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Gorseclaw (TC).kit.png - pattern redo for mackerel, to match with Tiger, Hawk and Bramble sets (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Gorseclaw (TC).star.png - pattern redo for mackerel, to match with Tiger, Hawk and Bramble sets (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Tallstar.apprentice.png - match this and this
 * File:Tallstar.kittypet.png - match this and this
 * File:Tallstar.rogue.png - match this and this (Reserved to Fox)
 * File:Tallstar.deputy.png - match this and this
 * File:Tallstar.star.png - match this and this
 * File:Stripes.rogue.png - match old pattern
 * File:Flaxfoot.kit.png - match og kit (Reserved to Thunder until 12 November)
 * File:Flaxfoot.apprentice.png - match og kit (Reserved to Thunder until 12 November)
 * File:Flaxfoot.warrior.png - match og kit (Reserved to Thunder until 12 November)