Forum:What Would Happen If The Books Turned Out Different?

Ever wondered what would happen if Swiftpaw didn't die or Silverstream lived after her kitting? Or what if Cinderpelt healed? OR better yet, if Firestar never joined ThunderClan?!?! Here is what I think:

First off, if Rusty styed with his TwoLegs after all, Tigerclaw would have ruled. After killing Redtail he would kill Ravenpaw, Lionheart, and then Bluestar. He would join with RiverClan first after Crookedstar dies (since Leopardstar is so easy to conrol). ShadowClan would also be easy to take under power with Brokenstar as leader. Tigerclaw would probaly end up conquering WindClan the bloody way. The forest would be under power of Tigerclaw as TigerCLan, StarClan would be angry or maybe not?

If Cinderpelt healed, I bet she would have told Fireheart her true feelings. They would be mates after all and Sandstorm would mate with Dustpelt. (I think SandxDust sounds a little weird anyway) I don't know who would take her place as medicine cat though. And I think the Power of Three Series would be a little different too.

IF Silverstream lived, things would probaly still be the same. Feathertail and Stormfur would have to stay in RiverClan with their mother. ThunderClan and RiverClan will still know they are half-clan, but at least Silverstream would be alive and they would know ther mother. And in The Sight, Graystripe wouldn't have brought Millie back with him.

IF Swiftpaw lived after the dog attack, he along with Brightheart would become a warrior. I think his warrior name should be Swiftclaw or Swiftpelt. (I like Swiftclaw better thought)

And also if Feathertail lived, she would have broken the warrior code, mated with Crowfeather, and their would be half-RiverClan, half-ThunderClan, and half-WindClan kits in RiverCLan. Geez, Feathertail's whole family are code-breakers! Silverstream with Graystripe and Stormfur had a crush on Squirrelflight and then mated with Brook!

So that's what I think. What do you think? And if I forgot any other tragedies that could have changed, add them in your response! :)