Forum:Brakenfur not Ashfur!

<!-- Please put your content under this line. I know everyone thinks it was Ashfur that betrayed ThunderClan, but no it wasn't. Here's what I think. Brakenfur is described as one of the best warriors in the Clan. He is a seneior warrior with a mate and kits. But being a senior warrior, he could've been made deputy. Firestar would've done it, unless Leafpool had told him about her sign. Also Brakenfur mentions that he learned more from Greystripe then any cat, when Firestar says he's dead. In Secrets of the Clans Brakenfur says Greystripe was very busy those days. Strange when Fireheart did most of his mentoring, Brakenfur didn't realized what his mentor did, after the truth came out about Silverstream. Also Ashfur's idea that Leafpool ploted to make her sister's mate deputy, was quickly put down by Brakenfur. Don't you think that Brakenfur would've been hurt when Firestar said his beloved mentor was dead? And Tigerclaw expected to be made deputy when Lionheart was, how cwould Brakenfur feel when his the leader's daughter's mate was choosen when Brakenfur has much more expirence and Brableclaw never even had an apprentice. I think he met Hawkfrost on the ShadowClan border, plotted for Ashfur to see Brambleclaw kill Firestar, and then have Hawkfrost kill Brambleclaw anyway, so Hawkfrost wouldn't be exiled. Does Hawkfrost seem like he'd share power? Well, there you go I have an idea why Hollypaw will be evil but that's another day. An thoughts? ~