Forum:Ashfur and Leafpool?

Could Ashfur be the three's father? State your opinion here!

Here's what I think:
 * Crowfeather=WWWAAAYY too obvious
 * Leafpool grieved grieved for him like a mother for her kit! There's probably something going on!
 * His pelt color works better-I can take a while to get genes from people other than your parents
 * Ashfur is just like Jayfeather
 * Leafpool's punishment- she mated with a traitor that tried to kill her father AND son
 * Or her mate dies as punishment
 * Ashfur mentors Lionblaze!
 * When Leafpool is trying to tell Crowfeather something, she might have wanted to tell him she has another mate, but she is shocked and surprised-and disappointed- when he told her he ALSO mated with someone else
 * Ashfur's CotC page- he has a story of his own(line)
 * He probably wouldn't have known about the kits
 * The kits are not in any way like Crayfishfeather!!!!!!!1111!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!!1!

All Users, one and all, state you opinion here:User:Mallinois 01:36, 14 November 2008 (UTC)

I'd rule out the fact that Ashfur mentored Lionblaze, Firestar picks that, and he isn't likely to know.-- Jakko 123  14:51, 14 November 2008 (UTC)

That is messed up. I wouldn't believe untill I saw it in black and white. Even then I'd beleive they could be lying. Ashfur would not mate with Leafpool, and you guys are reading too much into the After Sunset play. <3 User:Silvertree 17:05, 14 Novenber 2008

I totally support this. Crowfeather is too obvious, and the Erins don't do obvious. And the CotC page, i agree. And Jayfeather is not like Crowfeather, Breezepelt is like Crowfeather, but Jayfeather is not like Breezepelt. P.S. who is CrayfishfeatherThornclaw 22:55, 14 November 2008 (UTC)

Crayfishfeather..I must have been thinking about somrthing else and typed Crayfishfeather instead of CrowfeatherUser:Mallinois 04:04, 15 November 2008 (UTC)


 * they ignore each other
 * when Leafpool is around Crowfeather, she might act like that to make Ashfur jealous
 * Ashfur is older than Crowfeather, so he is probably a more experianced warrior and some of his skills seem like Lionblaze's, which might have been why Ashfur mentored him so easily, as with Birchfall because thaey are kin.
 * Plus, if you look at the three's CotC pic, you'll notice they look like Ashfur.....

More proof. Comment as you please.User:Mallinois 13:39, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

Not true. User:Silvertree 8:50, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

Wierdest proof of all. When Ashfur died, and Firestar inspects him, he asks who could have done this. LEAFPOOL suggests Windclan suspiciosly, so could she be suspicios of a cer tain tom that might have drowned Ashfur out of jelousy? Now what do you think?User:Mallinois 14:11, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

Not true. User:Silvertree 10:12, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

Silvertree, if you think it is not true please stop visiting this forum.User:Mallinois 16:09, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

I just looked at the CotC pics for Ash and Jay, and I saw that Ash looks like a spotted Jayfeather! They even have the same amount of muscle and fur, about the same is what it looks like! Proof I tell ya, proof!User:Mallinois 16:12, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

"Comment as you please." You said this did you not? No one said I could not make a comment that disagreed with the idea. I am just stating my opinion. <3 User:Silvertree 11:15, 15 November 2008

I agree with Silvertree. The Erins maybe don't want to be too obvious, but unless Vicky's been eating too much chocolate, they aren't gonna do leafxash. I was beginning to think that anything could happen after SpiderxDaisy, but this is just too messed up. Maybe they're trying to trick us; when it says that leaf mourned for ash like a mother for her kit, maybe that was just good old med cat love. I think that Cinderpelt said once that even though she would have liked to have been a warrior and have kits, she now got to have everyone as her kits that she took care of. Jayfeather probably just ignored this most of the time, but after hearing about how Squirrelflight wasn't his mother, his eyes and ears were open for just one little clue. LeafxCrow=Jay and Holly forever!--Shaf Girl 17:39, 15 November 2008 (UTC)

Yay! Someone agrees with me! That makes me happy! Go Shaf Girl! <3 User:Silvertree 12:45, 15 November 2008

Well, I believe this theory, it makes more sense than CrowXLeaf= Jay, Holly, Lion. Thornclaw 18:13, 15 November 2008 (UTC)