Forum:Screening Process Proposal Vote

This is a vote to implement the following system into PCA:

Basically, this is what the proposal would start in the project:


 * All new members will initially be kits, but will be promoted to apprentice as soon as they upload an image that is 50% complete.
 * Users that remain kits for one month may be asked to take mentors to help improve themselves.


 * All members of the project will be expected to have images at least 80% done when said images are uploaded for approval, or two senior members of the project will be allowed to, upon agreement, automatically decline the image.
 * If an image is at least 50% complete, it is to be given a week to improve itself to 80% completion before being auto-declined.
 * An image posted by a kit should be marked as "for evaluation" instead of "for approval" so that senior members can more easily find them.
 * Senior members are expected to remain courteous and polite when auto-declining an image, as always.
 * If the auto-decline of an image is under conflict, the deputy and leader of PCA must agree on an outcome together. If the deputy and leader cannot come to an agreement, a staff member of the wiki not involved in PCA may be contacted to resolve the conflict.

Completion of submitted projects may be determined by the chart below:

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/warriors/images/archive/2/2f/20111230040059!Shellyheart.png This charart is 10% completed or less. It is the wrong size, has blurred lineart, and is all around incorrectly done. This would be automatically declined by two senior warriors.

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/warriors/images/archive/2/2f/20111230040122!Shellyheart.png This charart is a hypothetical try by a user of Graystripe as an apprentice. It’s about 30% done. The colors are wrong and it lacks background opacity and shading, though it is the right size and has no blurred lineart. This would also be auto-declined by two senior warriors.

http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/warriors/images/archive/2/2f/20111230040142!Shellyheart.png This is Graystripe as an elder. It is about 50% done. Its colors are correct and its design is as well, but it lacks shading and ear pink. It may or may not be auto-declined, depending on the opinions of the ones deciding, but an apprentice proposing it shows that they know the basics and would be promoted to apprentice.

http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/warriors/images/archive/2/2f/20111230040157!Shellyheart.png This image that same image later. I’d call it 80% complete, and something that might come to a conflict. This image would be safe from auto-decline upon upload.

http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/warriors/images/archive/2/2f/20111230040217!Shellyheart.png This is that same image 90% completed. The back stripe and ear pink could be defined, but that’s about it. This charart would not fall under speculation by senior warriors and would proceed as normal. Again, any kit posting this would automatically become an apprentice.

This process has been thoroughly discussed here and here for the last several weeks.

The vote below is simple. Add your vote and a comment to the section below that you support.

Adopt the Process

 * 1) I truly believe that this process will help to streamline the approval page, and that the discussion has been given enough time for the entire project to contribute to it, to the point that it will work for everyone. 03:13, January 22, 2012 (UTC)