Forum:Now that Ash is out...

Well, thanks to pure logic, LeafxAsh has been put out of the picture. For those of you who haven't heard my theory, think of it this way: we know that Ashfur, whether he was the father or not, didn't know anything about the kits. And we know that in "After Sunset", Leafpool was going to tell Crowfeather the kits, whether he was the father or not. But if Ashfur was the father, wouldn't Leaf tell him first? So it's completely impossible.

So, now that Ash is out...who is it? This logic only 100% destroys LeafxAsh. There could be some tom--Stormfur, perhaps, or maybe even Thornclaw--who is keeping a secret that could be so shocking the no-sudden-change-allowed warriors would go nuts and think StarClan betrayed them. Somehow, I doubt it; Crowfeather is the most likely canidate now. So...what do you thing?--Shaf Girl 02:16, 25 January 2009 (UTC)