Talk:Applefrost/Archive 1

Gender
If they, Shyheart, and Willownose were mentioned to probably be the mother of Shellheart, wouldn't that make these cats female? 3:19 Tue Jan 20
 * No, because we don't know which cat they're talking about. Vicky thinks it's Willownose, I believe. That's assuming a gender.

If you look at each cat's page, Applefrost shows up as a brother to Willownose on her page, and Willownose and Shyheart both show up as sisters on Applefrost's page. Although this could be a mistake, we can assume that Willownose and Shyheart are both she-cats and Applefrost is a tom. --Olivebreeze (talk) 01:05, December 1, 2017 (UTC)

Summary
I haven't read Mapleshade's Vengeance yet, but in the summary, it repeats the name Appledusk, this article is about Applefrost. Is it a typo or do I just not understand?KarenWing (talk) 13:26, May 20, 2017 (UTC)

That leads me to wonder if he should have a history section at all, since he never formally appeared.

Is he mentioned in the Allegiances? If so many pages say, "Doesn't formally appear but listed in the Allegiances."KarenWing (talk) 14:31, May 20, 2017 (UTC)

It's because Applefrost is one of the unborn kits of Appledusk and Reedshine. idk, but that's the best we have.