Forum:Why i DON'T believe in the CrowxLeaf=Jay theory

Here are some thigns why i do not believe in the theory 1. People said she was getting noticeably fat- I dont remember anything in the books saying she was getting noticeably fat 2. I heard someone say all the chapters in Firestars Quest had Leafpools picture on them- It didn't, it had Firestars 3. Squirrelflights milk never came- Sandstorm had the same problem 4. Jaypaws fur color- he couldn't have gotten it from Crowfeather his is almost black and Jaypaws a lighter gray tabby. 5. Jaypaws snow dream- people say leafpool and Squirrelflight were with him and his littermates, and Leafpool gave birth, NO! They need a medicine cat to help them give birth 6. Jaypaw fell into the water- Crowfeather probably saved him becuase Windclan don't leave cats to die in thier time of need 7. Leafpools connection with Starclan- Of couse she has a connection with Starclan shes a medicine cat! And Jaypaw didn't get his connection from Starclan because of Genetics he got it because of the powers, the blidness, and yeah, HE'S A MEDICINE CAT 8. Erin Hunter would have gave Straightfoward hints Thornclaw 01:38, 22 August 2008 (UTC)