Forum:Discussion on Revising the Tweaking Process

So I proposed here that we should revise the tweaking process. This is the continued discussion.

Right now, the tweak page is set up with two headings: Needing Tweaking and Needing Make-overs. I'm proposing that we change that. The new system would look something like this:

We would have two headings: "Nominations", and "Approved Tweaks". Under each heading would be two subheadings, labelled "Tweaks" and "Redos". If you wish to nominate an image, you link the image like normal underneath the appropriate subheading, and list the reason(s) you wish it to be redone/tweaked. After you have done that, three senior members must come along and vote. They will do so by using the appropriate templates - or  - and a justification of their own. The number of SMs must be three to make sure there is more than one opinion and that there cannot be a tie.

After the nomination is voted on, there can be two results: passing or failing. If the vote passes, it is archived in a subpage somewhere and the image is put underneath the "Approved Tweaks" heading and the appropriate subheading. If the vote fails, it is archived in a subpage, but not added to the "Approved Tweaks".

Once an image is under the "Approved Tweaks" heading, it may be reserved on the project main page and crossed out with a and a.

An example of what it would look like is this:

Tweaks
File:Fleck.loner.png I think the shading could be redone. I disagree. It's lovely as it is. 04:03 Sat Jan 21 Yeah it's fine as it is. 04:03 Sat Jan 21 Agreed. Ivy did a lovely job and it doesn't need to be fixed. 04:03 Sat Jan 21

Redos
File:Owlwhisker.kit.png Needs to be redone to match other images. 04:03 Sat Jan 21 No discussion necessary. 04:03 Sat Jan 21 No brainer. 04:03 Sat Jan 21 Yup. 04:03 Sat Jan 21

Tweaks
File:Wildheart7.png Shading needs to be blurred.

Redos
File:Wildheart7.png Pattern needs to be redone to match description and shading darkened.  -- Comments on improving should be left below.