Talk:StarClan

Current

 * Needs a huge clean-up. I will try to get to this soon if I can.
 * Citations needed for (ultimately) all the confirmed members.  insaneular    Talk  02:22, March 24, 2010 (UTC)
 * I did a huge clean-up of the Description; the History still needs a cleanup. Helixtalk 18:49, April 13, 2010 (UTC)

Older

 * Spoiler free introduction that is not sections needs to be created.
 * Fixed but if anyone disagrees they are welcome to edit--Shippofox 14:18, 11 April 2008 (UTC)


 * Looks fine to me. Eu  ( Talk!

Contribs ) 15:18, 11 April 2008 (UTC)


 * Isn't the mention of the Moonpool a spoiler? Maybe not, but I would say it is...- Sparrowwing  talk  23:36, 31 May 2009 (UTC)


 * Information section needs to be worked in more completely with the rest of the page. Perhaps as a 'Facts & Trivia' section? Maybe discuss the matter.
 * Improve history layout. Multiple level headlines are needed for sorting.
 * Add pretty logo image in. Eu ( Talk! Contribs ) 15:38, 11 April 2008 (UTC)
 * Add a link titles "List of all StarClan Cats", linked to Category:StarClan Cat (Category-implementation is Project Characters)

StarClan vs. SkyClan Ancestors
Okay. Forgive me if my facts aren't 100% straight, because I haven't read Firestar's Quest in a while and honestly wasn't paying great attention to SkyClan's Destiny. Anyways, after reading SD I believe the lines between SkyClan Ancestors (who, according to FQ, separated themselves from StarClan) and their StarClan 'enemies' have become blurred. My suspicions come from the fact that 'SkyClan Ancestors' aren't referred to at all in the book and that some supposed SkyClan Ancestors (Cloudstar, Skywatcher, maybe others) appeared in this book and were labeled as StarClan cats. So what I'm asking you guys is: are they really different groups anymore? I think it's possible that this was just an oversight from the authors (wow what a shocker) or that perhaps the SkyClan Ancestors came to terms with StarClan and decided to re-join them? Shall we decide to take in this apparent change of situation, and group these cats together, or dismiss it as an oversight or consistency error? If we take it as fact, then we can alter the article accordingly, but if we decide to dismiss it, we should definitely have an article and category for SkyClan Ancestors - I'm surprised we don't already. So, opinions, comments, or statements of obvious facts that I may have missed? 23:35, August 27, 2010 (UTC)

I just skimmed Firestar's Quest this weekend to update the Cliffnotes page for Project Books, so I can help out here. :) They are almost always referred to as "SkyClan ancestors" instead of "StarClan cats"; for instance when Leafdapple is getting her nine lives (pages 486-492). It is mentioned that the SkyClan ancestors were scattered and unable to walk SkyClan's skies after the Clan vowed to never look at the stars again (page 497), but after they regain their faith, the ancestors are "coming home" and reuniting to watch over SkyClan (page 491). It is not confirmed whether they come to terms with StarClan though. 07:01, August 30, 2010 (UTC)