Warriors Wiki talk:Books

A Vision of Shadows
So everyone keeps trying to add what they think the book order is, but do we have any concrete proof that it does in fact go in the following order:
 * The Apprentice's Quest -> Thunder and Shadow -> Shattered Sky -> Darkest Night ????

Because we do have Hawkwing's Journey and now Tigerheart's Shadow to worry about... the blurb for Tigerheart's book clearly states it's after something with Darktail, so we can rule out it being before TAQ, TAS, and HJ... but where the heck does Hawkwing's story fit into this timeline? While the main part of the book appears to take place before TAQ, there's also this... extremely heavily implied thing with Pebbleshine and Hawkwing. Which we'll find out the answer to that soon enough, so should we just hold off (still) on adding the order until we get the next couple books??

Well, I say we wait on the Tigerheart book at least until it's released, since it could be after either SS or DN, so...
 * It might be worth noting that TF pretty much completely overlaps the events of Rising Storm, yet we placed it previous to it, since it started just a few days before. I think the same might apply to HJ - while some events do happen after TAQ & TAS, it starts before both and could be placed that way.

Well, I definitely think we should leave Shattered Sky and Darkest Night alone at least, with Tigerheart's Shadow in mind. We have no idea whether it's during them or between them or after them... As for the Hawkwing book, I think we can say it starts before TAQ since SkyClan had already been driven out then (and then you have that Pebbleshine thing). If it's just based on when the book started, HJ should definitely go first, but if not we should wait until the two timelines (TAQ/TAS and then HJ) merge. 21:55, February 16, 2017 (UTC)

I agree with Ivy, that we should for sure leave Shattered Sky and Darkest Night. I think HJ should be added as before TAQ, since it clearly does start before, but at the book takes place over the span of like, 2 years... 15:14 Sat Feb 18

Does anyone here think asking Kate might be a good idea? She's writing Tigerheart's Shadow, after all. She may have an idea as to the proper book order here. While I'm okay with adding Hawkwing's Journey before The Apprentice's Quest, Maple brings up a good point about how much time it spans... at least when Bluestar's Prophecy was out, the amount of time it spans really wasn't an issue.

I think asking Kate is a good idea....however vague the response may be. 18:49, February 19, 2017 (UTC)

Well, it's not like we'd be asking for spoilers or anything. We do need to know for the timeline and our articles. She used to be able to help if she could when it came to that...as long as people aren't asking because they want spoilers; that's a huge pet peeve and puts us in a bad light.

Oh yes, I do understand. So would we be allowed to ask that it's for the Wiki article *in this case, or...

and I do think she might not know which is why it would be vague. But that's just my speculation, this has no backing. 18:54, February 19, 2017 (UTC)

I think asking Kate would be a good idea. The only thing it could end up spoiling is that it might prove that the theory about Hawkwing and Pebbleshine isn't likely to be true, if HJ takes place a long time before TAQ. 22:38 Sun Feb 19

Sunrise/Chapter 19 ~ Silver Nomination
Credit to all that worked on this page. Boi, I looked at the talk page and it said [planned]. I'm just like 'Mhm, so true' XD. 18:49, February 20, 2017 (UTC)
 * Add a quote
 * I'm fairly sure the character lists are incomplete, cause I can see from the summary that there's at least 6 cats missing.
 * For the bottom few paragraphs, perhaps combine them, since they seem a bit short
 * The summary is also largely unlinked

Updated 19:28, February 20, 2017 (UTC)


 * Split the character lists
 * The summary is only half complete - it stops at page 232, but the chapter ends at 236, so there's 4 more pages to summarize.