Forum:Hollyleaf is Alive

I still believe that Hollyleaf is alive. When the rockfall happened, her brothers only imagined that she had been crushed to death. I think that this is the sort of loophole that is made in a Warriors story on purpose so the authors can create a surprisng (or not-so surprising) event in the future.

''Reasons;

1)  Hollyleaf didn't have a power I don't think that is right. She could feel a power inside of her. I think it may be the power to know what is wright or wrong, the power to make good decisions, or the power to change the warrior code. All of these ideas (except maybe the Changing-the-warrior-code one) have their merits.

2)  Hollyleaf isn't a member of the three I don't think that is right. When starclan are fretting about them they always include Hollyleaf, and talk about her as equally as Jay and Lion. How can, logically, those two be members of the three, but not her?

3) Dovekit or Ivykit will be a member of the three I think that one of them will be the fourth apprentice, but for the reasons above I don't think that either is a member of the three.

Now that I have establised that Hollyleaf MUST be a member of the three, I will now show you that she is alive.

4)Jayfeather could see a picture in his mind of hollyleaf being crushed by rocks. It was his imagination. No one (But Hollyleaf, Starclan, and the Erins) actually knows what happened in the rockfall. Chances are she missed it, or it missed her. As I said earlier, this is the kind of loophole that the Erins make and use regulary.

5)  'Another warrior will be lost forever' . Easy, thats (*sob*)Honeyfern, not Hollyleaf. Poor Honeyfern didn't deserve to die just to trick people into thinking that Hollyleaf was dead.''

I have lots of proof here that she is alive. I just refuse to belive that she is dead! If anyone has any counter evidence that i have not used in this, write that so that I can find some counter-counter-evidence! lol Dawnfeather  11:28, 6 May 2009 (UTC)