Warriors Wiki talk:Charart/Archive 94

Pink Eyes
Pink Eyes should probably have well, pink eyes, not blue with a pink pupil. I know most albinistic cats have eyes like Pink Eyes' image, but some do have pure pink eyes. He is both mentioned to have pink eyes and named "Pink Eyes", so I think it is right to assume that his eyes are not blue. 00:18, October 28, 2015 (UTC)

Nope, that's an assumption. If most cats with albinism have blue eyes with a pink pupil, then it would be safe and the proper thing to depict him with that description. Pink Eyes is a special character and we have to portray him properly. It's better to go with what we know about a real cat that has this, instead of assuming something based on his name.

We have cites that say he has pink eyes. Pale, milky, rosy pink eyes infact. That sounds pink to me. 00:27, October 28, 2015 (UTC)

Then if there's a cite, change the eye color. Princess did not say there was a cite, and it looked like she just wanted to change the eye color based on his name alone. Which there are websites that clearly state the cat can have light blue eyes.

When I said he was mentioned with pink eyes I meant there was a cite. Sorry if I wasn't clear enough. 00:42, October 28, 2015 (UTC)

Anyway, there is a cite saying he has pink eyes, and I think his charart should reflect that. 3:26 Sat Oct 31

he does.....his puils are very obviously pink and pink tinted. 05:29, October 31, 2015 (UTC)

But pupil =/= eye. If it did, you could technically say nearly everyone of the chararts on here have black eyes. In every other situation that eye color has been described in warriors, it's referred to the iris rather than pupil, so it probably would have specified if the pupil was pink. I definitely think it should be tweaked.

Well, since he's confirmed to have albinism, that alone is grounds for the pinkish-tinted pupil. We don't need a cite that specifically says his pupil color for that. If the cite itself says he's got pinkish eyes, then just change it. That's how we've always done it...?

We have a cite for pink. That's it. albinism ≠ pink eyes. We have CITE just change it why are people being so adamant over this. 06:16, October 31, 2015 (UTC)

stop acting like youve never bitched at people. its not like the iris is part of the eye or anything but whatever, change it then. 06:18, October 31, 2015 (UTC)

There is a cite for albinism. Kate said herself that he is albinistic...and from what I've read it's rare for a full pink-eyed cat to be born. Albinism typically means pink pupils in cats. Leave it as it is. Light blue and pink is fine. 06:28 Sat Oct 31

Okay, the only cites we have for his eyes are the Path of Stars allegiances and him apparently having a "rosy gaze" which doesn't sound to me like definitive proof of him having full-on pink eyes, but whatever. The closest I came to finding cats with literal pink eyes is this. It's not a bright pink colour, it's more of a pale grey-blue with the slightest pink tint. So if you're going to make it 'pink' (which you shouldn't imo. The image is fine. Don't touch it if there aren't any real issues), you go for a colour like this. He's also going blind if I may point out. The colour of his eyes isn't going to be especially vibrant. 07:09 Sat Oct 31

In the alligiances he is said to have pink eyes. Literally, pink eyes. The images obviously have blue eyes, so we should change them. This is an albinistic cat I think has pink eyes, and this one definitely does. Here is another. 14:53 Sat Oct 31

We should've taken into account that the cats don't know what pupils are, so he may have just had blue-grey-ish eyes like what I linked and pink pupils. Those images either have filters or the eyes are completely glared. They're not good examples. And that last one...the pink part is skin. Not eye. 15:27 Sat Oct 31

Every article about albinistic cats I've read says they can have pink eyes. Pink-eyed albinistic cats are incredibly rare, but not impossible. Giving Pink Eyes blue eyes is an assumption--in fact, it contradicts his description. 16:07 Sat Oct 31

This is going to snowball into another fight so I'm archiving this.