Forum:Pinestar Theory

It feels weird for me to start a new theory, but it seems so OBVIOUS to me, so here it goes. *takes a deep breath* Pinestar is, not only the father of Tigerstar, but the father of Firestar and Scourge! There, I said it!

You might doubt it, but I have back-ups:

Somewhere it's been said, in either The Rise of Scourge or some Erin Hunter chat, that Firestar's and Scourge's father was ginger colored. Pinestar is said to be reddish brown, which is close enough.

Quince also mentioned that the father was a brave, warrior-type tom, and Pinestar was the leader of a whole Clan that decided to become a kittypet.

We know that Scourge was a kit when Tigerstar was an apprentice, and that Pinestar left when Tigerstar was a kit. Pinestar probably had another reason for becoming a kittypet besides loving the lifestyle; hotshot Clan leaders don't just give it all up to get their belly rubbed. I think he was in love with Quince, and around the time Tigerstar became an apprentice, Scourge was born. Then, for some reason, after a while, he mated with another she-cat, who had Firestar and Princess.

It seems odd, I know, but it makes sense. And that means that BramblexSquirrel.......ick, it's a good thing the Three aren't their kits....--Shaf Girl  02:09, 24 July 2009 (UTC)