Forum:Everyone who wants their opinion heard, over here!

I have looked on so many sights, heard so many opinions, that I thought that it would be nice to gather them in one convenient place. Here, please say your opinion about the warriors books: what you thought of past books, what you think will happen in later books, what was your favorite or least favorite book and for what reason, relationships, enemies, secrets that must be reveiled, what an apprentice or kit's name would be if they lived to become a warrior...all of that stuff. They can be positive or negative. Here, I'll state my own opinions: I like all of the characters and books in some way or another, but Fire and Ice, Rising Storm, and Moonrise got on my nerves. Fire and Ice and Rising Storm were way too fast, and I think that Fireheart and Cinderpelt should have mourned for Yellowfang more, and Moonrise was practically ruined because I kept thinking, "What about Feathertail? Couldn't she be the silver cat?" And I think Swiftpaw's warrior name would have been Swiftfoot, and Larchkit and Hollykit would have been Larchwing and Hollyheart. Also, I'm not suggesting this, but with all these crazy relationships going around, couldn't SwiftpawxBrightpaw be possible? Oh, and I believe in the Leafpool+Crowfeather=Jayfeather and Hollyleaf theory, and it will be reveiled in long shadows, same with the fact that Ashfur was the traitor, and Mothwing will die in Sunrise.--Shaf Girl 23:22, 26 September 2008 (UTC)

My opinions:

Ashfur plotted to kill Firestar with Hawkfrost and Blackstar. Ashfur is an enemy of Brambleclaw, and when Birchpaw was getting his assesment Ashfur was watching him ( mentors do that) and when Birchpaw saw Blackstar Ashfur came out and told Birchpaw to get Firestar alone. So Blackstar left and Ashfur went back to the Camp, Ashfur then ran into Squirrelflight and Leafpool and said he couldn't take him on it said nothing on Brambleclaws point of view that he ran into ashfur. Ashfur followed Squirrelflight and Leafpool but to find out that Firestar lived so he ran back to camp.

Thornclaw 00:57, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

I don't know how anyone can believe in the CrowXLeaf=Jay, Holly theory.

The only reason they have the power is because they have Firestars and Tigerstars blood in them, or else they wouldn't have power.Thornclaw 04:32, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

Well, I can understand that. It's a very good point. But perhaps starclan gave Jayfeather his powers, and they will give holly her powers in long shadows (well, i know from erin hunter that her power will be revieled in long shadows). Maybe violent powers like Lionblaze's result from being the grandson of Firestar and Tigerstar, and less violent powers like jay's and holly's (i think she will have a less violent power) can occur when starclan gives it to you. maybe starclan gave the powers to them to fight lionblaze, who could potentially be the evil cat. all will be revieled in long shadows. and you know thornclaw, you can say other opinions too, state as much as you want.--Shaf Girl 14:21, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

Good opinions. Though Birchpaw could be in on the plan, too, and Ashfur wouldn't need to get Blackstar. I think Blackstar is a good guy, he just has lost a bit of faith in starclan, but i guess i would too with all that's happened to the clan cats. they seem to be way overdependant on starclan.--Shaf Girl 14:50, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

Ok, plz, i am hoping for more opinions here!--Shaf Girl 00:39, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

My Opinions: LeafxCrow is NOT true!!!!I think it's LeafxAsh because they seem to ignore each other a lot that might be why.--Bluestar&#39;sSecondDeputy 15:27, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

LeafxAsh....hmmm......well, possibly. It would definetly surprise everyone. But there is a ton of proof on this one forum topic on warriors wish. There was that one time when leaf and holly were training, and holly was really fast, and there was another time when jay felt the wind in his fur and he loved it. Those are signs of a windclan cat.--Shaf Girl 16:44, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

I'm starting to think it's Spiderleg. Cause some proof,and the amber eye hint thingy.Where they say that the charecter has amber eyes,but they don't. :) Like Lion thought an amber eyed fox was holly,then in eclipse it says Sol has amber eyes,but he has yellow.-- Jayfeather Sheikah 18:45, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

The erins tend to mix things up like that a lot. And you don't have to state about the leaf theory. state whatever you want.--Shaf Girl 19:32, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

I don't believe any of the Leafx(place tom prefix here) theories. My opinions about different cats vary. Firestar: the most ideal leader ever. Graystripe: interesting because he changed when Firestar came to the forest. There should be a super edition about him. Sandstorm: her name is a real word which slightly bugs me and she shouldn't have worried about her and Firestar's relationship in the Super Edition. Cinderpelt: it's good and kinda freaky she came back to life. Leafpool: Crowfeather changed her and I don't like that. Leafpool can be really mean when she's angry. Squirrelflight: i liked her when she was a hyper apprentice better. Brambleclaw: a good role model. Ashfur: boo. Brightheart: not fair what happened to her. Jaypaw: super cool i don't think he should've been blind. Hollyleaf: too serious. Lionblaze: even more super cool than Jaypaw. Sandtalon 21:50, 29 September 2008 (UTC)Sandtalon

" Ashfur: boo." LOL Thornclaw 21:59, 29 September 2008 (UTC)


 * I totally believe the L+C=J theory (not Holly!), but wouldn't be that surprised if it wasn't true. Any other LeafxTom theories are weird. I totally love Firestar but am morbidly fascinated with his approaching death (which will probably happen in the last ever book, I think).


 * About the powers: I think something bigger than StarClan gave them to the trio, and I can't wait to find out what that secret was the the StarClan cats were talking about in the prologue in Eclipse.


 * Sol is EVIL (with capital letters), Ashfur helped (almost) kill Firestar but now feels really bad about it, Cinderheart will eventually work her way up ThunderClan and become leader, and the Fourth Apprentice will either be someone we haven't met yet or someone totally obvious we haven't thought of yet. Oh, and I like the new fiesty Leafpool. I always thought she was way too much of a wimp befoe she toughened up. Rainpaw  (talk!)  02:04, 1 October 2008 (UTC)