Warriors Wiki talk:World

Timeline Issues
So I've been looking through the timeline for a while, and there are some major things that are incorrect or completely and totally assumed on there. A ridiculous amount. For instance, we don't even know when Bluestar was made leader and we assumed that, we don't know how long she lived between then and when Rusty arrived. YS can't even be added in there because of the errors, and I do believe there are a lot of issues in CP's timeline on there now too. I haven't thoroughly checked much of the main series, but I do know there are some big errors and assumptions in there too.

Some of these errors put on there completely throw off the rest of the timeline an countless ages. Vicky has announced there will be a full timeline of all the books inside the jacket of the new field guide. I personally think we should publicly declare the timeline unusable until that book comes out, or the Erins confirm themselves when some of the events were placed. I've checked for cites on some of these errors and there are absolutely none in the book to indicate when they happened. With them being such major events and being all through the whole timeline with no way of fixing them, I think something needs to be done. Whatever it may be. Feel free to suggest whatever you think would be the best way, but as I said before I think we should just shut it down for now, or put a warning or something.

Suggestions?

Marking it inaccurate would label the wiki inaccurate and we already have issues with that on Vicky's Facebook and Kate's blog. I also wouldn't trust the full timeline in the new field guide because it's probably taken from the "official" website or it's something put together just for making it. I think we'd probably tear this "new timeline" apart with just the amount of amassed errors we could point out. In any case however, we can always just start from scratch thus deleting it, or even moving the coding to a subpage and working on a new timeline. 01:29, March 27, 2013 (UTC)

I honestly think that the page should be deleted. It was never really "finished" and as it is now with so many flaws we'd basically have to start from scratch. With countless time errors in the books it would be harder than it's worth to finish. The full timeline, like 'teldy said, would probably be full of errors. I think it should be deleted. A disclaimer would  be marking the entire wiki as inaccurate and that's not something we want. So yeah... 06:21, March 30, 2013 (UTC)

I agree with Duck, actually. I've tried to edit that timeline, and I get so confused as to what goes where, and what exactly counts as a cite, and what doesn't. The references are so skewed and jumbled, that nothing truly makes sense. Added to the fact that we can't put an accurate order on the books, due to multiple factors, the timeline should really be deleted, or perhaps moved to a project subpage and say that it's an interpretation based on the wiki's evidence, and it's an ongoing event or something along those lines, perhaps? I'm not sure how you guys want to go about it, but it's plain as day that the current timeline is extremely inaccurate and needs to be fixed, whether it be by deleting the current one, or just throwing the timeline altogether.

MAJOR PROB HERE!!!!!
Ok so i just finnished reading the Sun Trail and i thought "Man how long ago would this be from firestar if the CARS have the same discription from the OTHER series... just thought id point that out.

I haven't read The Sun Trail yet but if you think about putting the series on a realistic timeline, then it probably could be considered about maybe a little less than century. Considering that cars became a popular item in around the "roaring 1920s" in that many more people could afford them and that the patterns of cars haven't really changed that much within the decades, it's pretty well plausible that where the Dawn of the Clans arc begins, it could really date back to the 1900s in relation with human society, or even the late 1800s. It's all theoretical though, but it would make for a nice discussion or blog. 17:56, June 27, 2013 (UTC)

May I Join?
Hi, I'm Amber. May I join project world?--Ambershine223 (talk) 16:11, July 10, 2013 (UTC)

Of course! Please read the guidelines! Welcome to PW! c: 18:18, July 14, 2013 (UTC)

August FA
Mates looks good, any comments/suggestions? 18:20, July 14, 2013 (UTC)

Mates look good, and it looks up to date c: 18:23, July 14, 2013 (UTC)

Mates looks fine to me. 19:02 Sun Jul 14 2013

Okay, so CBV? 01:52, July 23, 2013 (UTC)

Vote's up! 21:20, July 24, 2013 (UTC)

Rejoin
Can I rejoin? 23:34, 07/20/2013

Of course! Please refresh your memory of the guidelines if needed. Welcome back~ 01:59, July 21, 2013 (UTC)