Forum:Proof that Heathertail DID NOT tell Windclan about the tunnels

I have lots of proof that Heathertail didn't betray Lionblaze. I know this is an old subject, but I had to address it.

If Heatertail HAD told Windclan about the tunnels, she would have to be VERY angry at Lionblaze for ditching her. Angry enough to want her clan to attack his and try to drive them out. I don't think Heathertail would do a thing like that. Also, she might have told them about the tunnels so she would have a chance to attack Lionblaze and finally get some revenge. She would have been very HAPPY when he attacked her first, not SHOCKED. She tried to get away, remember, but if she had been truly angry at him she would have fought back. The only reason she acted so cold toward him in Long Shadows and Sunrise was because he attacked her.

On the other hand, if she DIDN'T told Windclan about the tunnels, she clearly still wanted Lionblaze to be her friend, just not meet every night. Like I said before, she was SHOCKED when Lionblaze attacked her. Maybe because she still believed they were friends? She struggled in his grip, didn't fight back, so she might have wanted to get away so she didn't have to fight her friend. And when he finally did confront her, she said "I don't lie! It wasn't me! It was Sedgekit!" No cat could make up a story like that in a few seconds. And don't you think if she had betrayed Lionblaze, she would have said something like, "Yeah, you bet I told Windclan, buster! Deal with it!" because she WANTED to fight him. It's just as likely for Sedgepaw to blurt out the tunnels were there by accident than Heathertail telling her clan on purpouse. I don't care WHAT Lionblaze or the Erins say, I will always believe Heathertail is innocent.