|"I know you think I've never forgiven Brambleclaw for stealing you from me, but you're wrong, and so is every cat that thinks so. My quarrel is with you, Squirrelflight. It always has been."|
|— Ashfur's confrontation with Squirrelflight in Long Shadows, page 273|
He is born to Brindleface along with his sister, Ferncloud. When Cloudkit comes into ThunderClan, he and Ferncloud has a foster brother once Brindleface took him in. He becomes an apprentice with the name of Ashpaw. When Bluestar asks Fireheart to choose Ashpaw's mentor, he chooses Dustpelt in hopes that the warrior would become more patient and kind with an apprentice. When Brindleface is killed by Tigerstar, Ashpaw and Fernpaw fight the dogs in honor of her.
He earns his warrior name, Ashfur, along with his sister Ferncloud. As a young warrior, he takes a liking to Firestar's daughter, Squirrelpaw. He mentors Birchpaw, Dustpelt and Ferncloud's only surviving kit. Although he and Brambleclaw were previously friends, Ashfur becomes jealous of his relationship with Squirrelflight and grows to dislike the tabby warrior. When Squirrelflight has a major fight with Brambleclaw, she becomes close to Ashfur and spends the majority of her time with him. Ashfur, having thought he had won Squirrelflight's love, is devastated and broken-hearted when she rekindles her relationship with Brambleclaw and the two become mates. He then becomes cold and callous towards Squirrelflight.
Ashfur receives Lionpaw as an apprentice and they begin a rather hostile and uneasy relationship, due to the fact that Lionpaw is Squirrelflight's son. He is often strict with his apprentice and is quick to criticize him. Even after Lionblaze is made a warrior, Ashfur and him fight with their claws unsheathed.
When a fire breaks out the ThunderClan camp, Squirrelflight takes all three of her kits and try to flee the area. Ashfur goes with them and when a burning branch falls, he blocks the only escape route. Ashfur tells Squirrelflight that he is still furious and heartbroken that she chose Brambleclaw instead of him, and wants to make her suffer like he did. He reveals that he helped Hawkfrost trick Firestar into the fox trap, and since that was unsuccessful, he will kill her kits instead. He is completely taken aback when Squirrelflight reveals that Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather are not her kits. He lets them leave unharmed but threatens to reveal the truth at the Gathering.
The night of the Gathering, Ashfur goes missing. His body is later found in the stream and many of his Clanmates think he drowned. However, Leafpool finds a tuft of Hollyleaf's fur between his claws and knew that Hollyleaf murdered him. She keeps this secret to herself and is devastated by the truth.
In the Super Editions
- Ashfur is a young warrior. He becomes good friends with the newly named Brambleclaw, Firestar's former apprentice. When Firestar leads an evening patrol to ShadowClan, he mentions that Brambleclaw hunted with Ashfur and Graystripe for most of the afternoon. After Brambleclaw's warrior vigil, Ashfur pads over to tell him his vigil is over. He leads Brambleclaw back toward the warriors' den and offers to help him find a place to sleep.
- When Smudge comes to visit Firestar and to warn him of Twolegs, Ashfur and Brambleclaw attack him to keep him from coming into the camp. Ashfur bites down hard on Smudge's tail, causing the kittypet to cry out in alarm. Firestar appears soon, demanding them to stop. Ashfur reluctantly stops fighting and calls Smudge a kittypet intruder. He is shocked when Firestar is welcoming to Smudge and doesn't want to leave the two alone together. However, he leaves to go on patrol with Brambleclaw, Dustpelt, and Mousefur.
- Ashfur then goes on patrol with Sootpaw, Thornclaw, and Willowpelt. The patrol runs into Firestar after his night spent with Smudge in the Twolegplace. Firestar helps Ashfur and the patrol renew the scent markers, and quickly after they scent a badger. After they are attacked by the badger, Ashfur helps fight it. He lunges at it from the side, but the badger is too fast and leaves a gash on his shoulder. The badger then knocks him aside, winding him. Willowpelt is also killed in the attack. After it leaves, Firestar sees Ashfur limp heavily from his shoulder wound and asks him if he is okay. Ashfur flexes his shoulder muscles and comments that he landed on it badly. He helps Firestar carry Willowpelt's body for burial, and later, Cinderpelt gives him some poppy seeds for his shoulder.
- When Firestar is preparing to leave and says his final farewells to the Clan, Ashfur is seen sitting with Brambleclaw and Mousefur.
In The Prophecies Begin arc
- He is one of the four newborn kits born to the ThunderClan queen, Brindleface, along with his sister and two brothers. He is seen mewling and squirming along with his littermates beside Brindleface's belly, still not having opened their eyes yet.
- It is mentioned that one of his littermates dies not long after birth despite being a healthy kit. When Fireheart brings Cloudkit into the camp, Fireheart asks Brindleface to care for him. At first she refuses, but eventually she accepts, though reluctantly.
- Brindleface later adopts Cloudkit, becoming a foster mother to him and making him her kits' adopted brother. After Sandstorm and Dustpelt's vigil, they report that the three kits have gone missing. Fireheart and Sandstorm go searching for them and manage to find him and his sister, although they cannot find Cloudkit.
- The three kits follow a ThunderClan battle patrol, hoping to participate in the fight. His other unnamed littermate dies of greencough later on.
- He, Cloudkit, and his sister go hunting, and Cloudkit manages to catch a small vole. The Clan is worried about the kits' disappearance, so Fireheart and Sandstorm go search for the trio, finding them near a log.
- Although unnamed, he appears several times. During Thornpaw and Brightpaw's apprentice ceremonies, Brindleface's kits stumble out of the nursery to watch. Soon after, when Brackenpaw, Sandstorm, and Fireheart hunt, Brindleface is in the hollow with her kits who scramble about the snow, and the queen explains that the kits need to stretch their legs, as the snow made them restless.
- After the battle with WindClan and ShadowClan, Brindleface brings her kits out to see what is going on. When Fireheart brings Graystripe's kits to the ThunderClan nursery, he sees Brindleface curled around her kits and Cloudkit. Before Cloudkit becomes an apprentice, he rushes to tell Fireheart about it, and Brindleface and her kits follow more slowly.
- He and his sister reach six moons of age and Bluestar tells Fireheart, who is the new deputy, to choose their mentors. Fireheart picks Dustpelt, in the hopes that he will become less irritable and Darkstripe at Yellowfang's recommendation. During the ceremony, he kneads his paws against the ground in excitement. After he gets his mentor, he purrs loudly and follows Dustpelt to the edge of the circle. Ashpaw is Dustpelt's first apprentice and this upsets Sandstorm because Fireheart picked Dustpelt to be a mentor and not her.
- Ashpaw later goes on his first patrol with Whitestorm and Sandstorm. The gray apprentice shows a strong friendship with Cloudpaw in this book, and Cloudpaw returns it, possibly because they were raised together.
- When Cloudpaw starts taking food from Twolegs, Ashpaw knows, but out of loyalty to his friend, he doesn't tell anyone about it. Later, after Fireheart learns that Cloudpaw had been kidnapped by Twolegs, Ashpaw goes to Fireheart to find out what happened, as ordered by Darkstripe. Fireheart gets mad and says that if Darkstripe wants to find out, he should have asked himself. Ashpaw apologizes, and adds that he is curious, too. When Fireheart tells him, Ashpaw becomes very frantic and upset.
- After Cloudpaw is rescued by Fireheart, Sandstorm, and Ravenpaw, Ashpaw is relieved to know that he is safe. Ashpaw bounds forward to touch noses with Cloudpaw. At the end of the book, Ashpaw is chosen to go to the Gathering where ThunderClan finds out that Tigerclaw is the new leader of ShadowClan.
- Dustpelt says he wants himself and Ashpaw to go on the dawn patrol. Fireheart calls out the apprentice's name as he lists the cats going on the patrol. Later, Ashpaw is seen working with Darkstripe, Fernpaw, and Dustpelt to patch the warriors' den. Later, as Fireheart is padding towards the Highrock, he sees Ashpaw and Swiftpaw scuffling outside the apprentices' den. After the Gathering, Fireheart sees Ashpaw and Cloudpaw patching the outer wall of the camp with twigs. Fireheart later notices that Ashpaw is guarding the entrance to the camp and asks him if he has seen Ravenpaw. Ashpaw tells him that he hasn't, and he is bursting with curiosity. As Fireheart turns to leave the medicine den, he hears a rustle and sees Ashpaw confronting Ravenpaw. Fireheart then sends the apprentice away to speak to his friend. When looking for Bluestar, Fireheart spots Fernpaw and Ashpaw sharing tongues outside the apprentices' den. He tells the two apprentices that he has a message for Bluestar, and they dash off.
- Ashpaw's foster brother, Cloudpaw, becomes a warrior named Cloudtail, despite Ashpaw and the other apprentices being older. Bluestar refuses to make the other apprentices warriors, due to her recent paranoia and war on StarClan. She only chooses Cloudtail because he had revealed his lack of belief in StarClan. Ashpaw and the other apprentices are angry with Bluestar because of this. Disgruntled with her reluctance to trust him and refusal to make him a warrior, Swiftpaw tells the other apprentices that they should all try to find out what was stealing ThunderClan's prey at the time; then Bluestar would have to make them warriors. Thornpaw, Ashpaw, and Fernpaw decline Swiftpaw's offer, but Brightpaw accepts. After the disappearance of Brightpaw, Fireheart suggests to Dustpelt that he should take Ashpaw, Fernpaw, and Darkstripe on a hunting patrol. Earlier the next morning, Fireheart sees Dustpelt calling Ashpaw out from the apprentices' den. Graystripe then takes the two on patrol.
- After uncovering the trail of rabbits, Fireheart and Cloudtail discover that Ashpaw's mother, Brindleface, had been killed by Tigerstar, who wanted to give a pack of fierce dogs a taste for cat blood. Ashpaw, Fernpaw, and Cloudtail carry out her burial. When Fireheart talks with the Clan and tells them about the dogs, both apprentices have a look of stunned horror on her face. After Fireheart announces his plan and his orders are being carried out, Fernpaw and Ashpaw pushing their way to the front of the crowd. Furious and grieving, Ashpaw and Fernpaw ask Fireheart if they can help lead the dogs to the gorge. Fireheart originally says no, but Ashpaw says they want to avenge their mother. The deputy agrees after being persuaded by Whitestorm. When Fireheart reaches the top of the ravine, he orders the apprentices to stay where they are, and run to the gorge when they see the dogs. He tells them the next cat in line is Sandstorm, and when they see her they need to climb a tree. The apprentices are told to head to Sunningrocks after the dogs pick up her trail.
- Fireheart looks down at Fernpaw and Ashpaw, their eyes gleaming in fury for Brindleface, grief for their mother momentarily forgotten in the desire to avenge her. He hopes that they will not forget their instructions and panic, or even try attacking the dogs by themselves. Fireheart tells them ThunderClan relies on them, and they're proud of them. Fernpaw says her and Ashpaw won't let him down, and with that Fireheart leaves them there. He tells Sandstorm to wait here so the apprentices don't have to run far.
- Fireheart sees Ashpaw and Fernpaw and congratulates them for outrunning the dogs. The apprentices let out a purr and Ashpaw says they hid in the hazel thicket and jumped out when they saw the dogs Fireheart praises them again and tells them Brindleface would be proud. Ashpaw shrinks back and confesses that he was actually terrified, and if they knew what the dogs were like they wouldn't dare do it. Dustpelt comforts him by telling him that everyone was as scared as he was. When Fireheart gets back from the Gathering, he is tired and shocked. He struggles to find the patrols, but Dustpelt kindly takes over, saying that he and Ashpaw will lead the dawn patrol. As leaf-bare comes, he is seen with his mentor, Dustpelt rebuilding the camp entrance.
- When Firestar comes back with his nine lives and leader name from StarClan, Ashpaw is the first cat to welcome him back. Before Whitestorm is made deputy, he talks with Ashpaw and Fernpaw. Later, when Firestar tells Mousefur about taking Thornpaw on the dawn patrol to see if he's ready to be a warrior, he says he'll talk with Fernpaw and Ashpaw too. After Firestar finishes eating with Sandstorm, he pads over to the tree stump and finds Ashpaw, Fernpaw, Dustpelt and Thornpaw. He promises Ashpaw and Fernpaw that they aren't forgotten, but are a bit too young to be warriors, and Ashpaw says he understands. When Cloudtail asks to know what happened to Sorrelkit, Ashpaw and Thornpaw bend over to share the news. Dustpelt asks if he could mentor both Fernpaw and Ashpaw, but Firestar says he wouldn't be tough enough on her.
- During Thornclaw and Lostface's warrior ceremony, Firestar gives thanks to Fernpaw and Ashpaw, and says they showed him their bravery in the dog attack. He says that although they are too young to become warriors, their Clan honors them. ThunderClan then shouts their names, which makes the apprentices overwhelmed. When Fernpaw receives Longtail as her new mentor, she dips her head to Ashpaw and Dustpelt. Firestar tells Whitestorm that he will be taking Fernpaw and Ashpaw to the Gathering. After the Gathering, when Bramblepaw is speaking to Firestar, he mentions that Ashpaw told him what Tigerstar said at the Gathering.
- Ashpaw is part of the rescue patrol to WindClan.
- When BloodClan comes to the forest, Ashpaw snorts when he sees their collars, exclaiming that they are kittypets, but he is quickly silenced by his mentor, Dustpelt. As Firestar emerges from his den the next morning, he sees Whitestorm with Bramblepaw and Ashpaw. Later, Ashpaw is seen training with Dustpelt, Cloudtail, and Brightheart. Ashpaw is thought of briefly by Firestar when he is acknowledging Dustpelt. During the battle with BloodClan, the deputy of ThunderClan, Whitestorm, is killed by Bone. Ashpaw and Bramblepaw immediately start attacking him, with Ashpaw going for Bone's legs. Firestar watches Bone struggle free from Ashpaw and Bramblepaw, but more apprentices join in, and in revenge for killing Whitestorm, Ashpaw, Tawnypaw, Bramblepaw, Featherpaw, and Stormpaw ambush the BloodClan deputy, avenging Whitestorm's death. After Bone goes limp and dies, Ashpaw yowls the victorious cry. The apprentices then attack Jaggedtooth and drive him away.
In The New Prophecy arc
- Ashfur is seen going out on patrol with Brambleclaw and Thornclaw. The patrol is told to check Snakerocks and to be careful of adders. Squirrelpaw is caught following the patrol, and after a bit of scolding, is ordered home. Ashfur points out that she'll be in trouble if Dustpelt goes looking for her. Angry and upset, Squirrelpaw begs Thornclaw to let her join them, and he eventually gives in.
- At Snakerocks, the four cats scent badger. Ashfur cautiously enters the cave, and is relieved when he sees the badger isn't home. Suddenly the badger appears behind them, and Ashfur dives into a bush. When the patrol escapes the badger, Ashfur wonders if it is the same one that killed Willowpelt last leaf-bare. The patrol is forced to return to camp early so they can alert Firestar. When they get back, he and Thornclaw describe what they saw to Firestar.
- In a Clan meeting about Firestar's patrol, Ashfur points out that the Twoleg monsters will frighten prey and asks what ThunderClan will eat. Later, he points out in another Clan meeting that fishing is too difficult for ThunderClan. Firestar chooses him to be part of the patrol that speaks to Tallstar about the lack of prey. On the way, Ashfur expresses anger with the WindClan cats for stealing prey, and disbelief towards Firestar when he orders to let the warriors go.
- When Mousefur wants to take a patrol, she asks Firestar if they should look for Cloudtail and Brightheart, who have disappeared. Ashfur seems to think that they left deliberately, adding that to the conversation. Firestar says to keep their eyes open while Mousefur grumbles that it wouldn't be past them to leave the forest in search of Twoleg food. Ashfur adds that he wouldn't either since Cloudtail ate it often as an apprentice.
- Ashfur is first seen when Squirrelpaw and Brambleclaw return from their long journey. Ashfur greets Squirrelpaw with surprise by reaching out to touch her muzzle with his and purring. When Whitepaw says that the Twolegs destroyed Fourtrees, Ashfur interrupts her, saying that they wouldn't have heard about it yet. Brambleclaw says they did hear about it from Webfoot. Ashfur is surprised, and asks if they were on WindClan territory.
- He is later seen guarding the fresh-kill pile, searching the sky to make sure hawks don't appear. When the Clan tries to convince Firestar to name a new deputy, as Graystripe has been captured by Twolegs, Ashfur stares at Brambleclaw, suggesting that he believes Brambleclaw is the logical choice.
- Ashfur is later seen on a hunting patrol with Firestar, Brambleclaw, and Squirrelpaw. After the patrol finds out that Tigerstar fathered Hawkfrost, he growls his beliefs that Hawkfrost shares Tigerstar's ambition to take over the whole forest. When Shrewpaw dies, Ashfur offers to take the squirrel Brambleclaw caught to Birchkit, since his mother Ferncloud wouldn't be able to feed him for a while due to her starvation and grief.
- When the Clans are leaving the forest and Sasha comes to ask Mothwing and Hawkfrost to leave RiverClan, Ashfur hisses threateningly at her, but is silenced by Firestar. In the mountains, he is bewildered when he sees where and how the Tribe of Rushing Water lives. Squirrelpaw encourages him to enter their cave, which he does.
- Ashfur is first mentioned by Brambleclaw while he's shifting around in the leaves. He misses the warmth of Squirrelflight next to him, and thinks she went to sleep with the flecked gray tom but he isn't quite sure. Later, when the ThunderClan cats find sleeping places in their new camp, Brambleclaw finds Squirrelflight with the younger warriors in a patch of ferns. He tries calling out to her, but she doesn't reply, and instead curls up with Ashfur, their dark ginger and gray pelts mingling together. The next day Leafpaw watches Brambleclaw bound over to Squirrelflight, but Ashfur walks up and tells the ginger she-cat that Sandstorm wants her for a hunting patrol, and Squirrelflight says she'll do it. Brambleclaw is visibly disappointed but doesn't complain. It is now obvious that Ashfur is in love with Squirrelflight.
- When Spiderpaw's warrior ceremony is about to start, Brambleclaw tries to sit next to Squirrelflight but finds she's already sitting with Ashfur, Rainwhisker, and Sootfur. Their heads are close together and shoulders shaking as if they were sharing a joke. Later, as ThunderClan is heading to the Gathering, Brambleclaw turns around and looks at Squirrelflight and Leafpaw walking together. He notes that Squirrelflight is not around Ashfur for once, and instead the gray tom is talking to Rainwhisker and Cinderpelt. He thinks that Ashfur spends too much time with Squirrelflight. During Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw's argument about Hawkfrost, Ashfur calls out to the ginger she-cat and tells her there's a spot next to him where she can sit. Squirrelflight gives Brambleclaw one last angry look before stalking away to join the gray tom. He calls for her to wait, but she doesn't look back. Brambleclaw thinks he will never chase her all the way over Ashfur, he doesn't want to give the young warrior satisfaction watching him and Squirrelflight fight.
- Before the Gathering starts, Brambleclaw thinks about how important Squirrelflight is and how she is sitting with Ashfur, the gray warrior bending over to whisper something in her ear. When Leafpaw is about to sit down, she spots Squirrelflight padding towards Ashfur. She feels the pangs of distress coming off her sister as if she were having them herself. After Firestar announces where ThunderClan's borders have been set, Ashfur yells out his approval. Soon a faint cloud covers the moon and the winds pick up, and Ashfur mutters the Horseplace isn't like Fourtrees back in the forest, and how he felt safe there. Leafpaw reminds him that StarClan is with them wherever they go, but her words don't seem to comfort him or the other cats. When the Gathering ends, Ashfur waits for Squirrelflight to catch up to him, and the two bound off.
- Later, Brambleclaw notices the fresh-kill pile is low, and asks Squirrelflight if she would like to hunt with him. Squirrelflight declines and says she's going hunting with Ashfur and Spiderleg. When Firestar calls a Clan meeting, Ashfur is seen pausing along with his hunting patrol, then they drop their prey and run over to the Highledge and sit down. After Firestar explains Mudclaw's attack, Thornclaw is assigned to watch the ShadowClan border, and Ashfur and Squirrelflight join him. During Mudclaw's attack, Brambleclaw spots Squirrelflight, Ashfur, and Thornclaw and is relieved reinforcements arrived.
- When Brambleclaw orders cats around, Spiderleg says that he is a bossy furball and that he thinks he's Clan deputy. Ashfur says that Brambleclaw is a good warrior, and that there's nothing wrong with wanting to be deputy, especially since Graystripe isn't there.
- Ashfur is seen on the patrol to see that Onewhisker has gotten his nine lives. When Squirrelflight and Ashfur are out collecting moss for the elders since there are no apprentices, Squirrelflight starts a game by flinging moss at Ashfur. He tries to get her, but when she's dodging it, she stumbles into Brambleclaw. He snaps at them, causing Squirrelflight to walk off in anger. When she gets attacked by a fox, Ashfur tries to help her, but Brambleclaw saves her instead. After they recover, they are sent to warn WindClan about the fox.
- At the first Gathering on the island, Squirrelflight and Ashfur explore the island together. Ashfur gets his first apprentice, Birchpaw, who is his nephew. Squirrelflight now spends more time with him than she does with Brambleclaw, who has been in a foul mood lately. She enjoys his company.
- Ashfur grows very close to Squirrelflight, trying to protect her from outside threats and Brambleclaw. When Squirrelflight runs over the border, Brambleclaw scolds her, but Ashfur tries to fight her battle for her. Sandstorm sees this and has a talk with Squirrelflight afterward. When Daisy brings her kits in, Ashfur says that they will be a great addition to the Clan, unlike Brambleclaw, who says they are kittypets; this makes Cloudtail and Squirrelflight argue because of their kittypet roots, being related to Firestar. When Leafpool runs away to be with Crowfeather, Squirrelflight wonders if she would run away with Ashfur if she had to. She believes she wouldn't, but she doesn't know if she would with Brambleclaw, who she is starting to grow close to again.
- Later, during the badger attack, Ashfur does his best to defend Squirrelflight from the attacking badgers, which irritates her, because she believes she is perfectly capable of defending herself.
- Ashfur is seen when Leafpool is bending over his limp body, causing Brambleclaw to wonder if he was dead. When Ashfur's tail then twitches, Brambleclaw determinedly thinks that StarClan will not claim all of the ThunderClan warriors that night. As Firestar speaks to Onestar, offering help from Leafpool to heal the warriors before they left, Leafpool remains crouched, only staring at Firestar when she is called. The WindClan cats begin to leave, causing Leafpool to scramble away from Ashfur to say farewell to Crowfeather.
- Brambleclaw, having accidentally snapped at Squirrelflight, apologizes, but Squirrelflight silences him, causing Ashfur to stare at Brambleclaw with narrowed eyes. Squirrelflight clearly doesn't notice him as she goes to greet Stormfur and Brook.
- Soon after the badger attack, Squirrelflight tells Ashfur that she and Brambleclaw have realized what they mean to each other, and that she isn't going to be his mate. Ashfur protests that he loves her. He is hurt and becomes extremely angry with both cats as he believes that Squirrelflight and he should be together. Also, he openly shows his mistrust of Brambleclaw, mainly due to Brambleclaw's father being Tigerstar, the murderous traitor who killed Ashfur's mother, Brindleface.
- Later, Firestar appoints Brambleclaw deputy after Leafpool received a sign from StarClan, which said that Brambleclaw should be ThunderClan's new deputy. Ashfur becomes furious with this, and he openly challenges this choice. He wonders why Leafpool had said Brambleclaw should be the new deputy; after all, her sister, Squirrelflight, was Brambleclaw's mate. At this, Squirrelflight becomes outraged and leaps at him, only to be stopped by Brambleclaw. Leafpool becomes utterly outraged as well, but no one else takes notice of Ashfur, and instead, they congratulate Brambleclaw. After the ceremony, he is the only one who doesn't congratulate Brambleclaw and is seen stalking off slowly to the warriors den.
- Later, before Brambleclaw goes to meet Hawkfrost for the final time, Ashfur says he's planning to give Birchpaw an assessment. But, not long after, Ashfur comes to Leafpool and Squirrelflight, saying he had seen Brambleclaw and Hawkfrost with Firestar, who is stuck in a fox trap. Ashfur couldn't have taken on Brambleclaw and Hawkfrost by himself, so he went back to ThunderClan for help. After he tells them this, Leafpool and Squirrelflight follow his fear-scent trail to where Firestar is trapped, but they arrive just after Hawkfrost is killed. Later, he reveals his part in the attempted murder of Firestar.
- Ashfur ends up ignoring Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight after this. Squirrelflight later says that when she greeted Ashfur, it was like he was staring straight through her, which hurts her feelings, as she wanted to be friends with him. Brambleclaw comforts her.
In the Power of Three arc
- Ashfur receives the newly named Lionpaw as an apprentice. They start off on an uneasy relationship, not forming the usual bond between mentors and apprentices. After the ceremony, Ashfur takes Lionpaw out on patrol.
- When Graystripe, ThunderClan's former deputy, returns, he has his new mate, Millie, with him. Some cats think that Brambleclaw should step down, and let Graystripe return to his old position, but, much to his Clanmates' surprise, Ashfur disagrees, saying Brambleclaw should stay where he is, and he is the first to start cheering for Brambleclaw. Ironically, Ashfur was the cat who spoke out against Brambleclaw during his deputy ceremony.
- When Ashfur returns from a patrol, he complains about ShadowClan, saying in a barbed statement that certain cats try to steal what another cat already has, making Squirrelflight flinch.
- He is seen in the patrol that finds out that ShadowClan is trying to ambush ThunderClan. After the ShadowClan warriors retreat, Ashfur and Brambleclaw are told to renew the scent markers on the correct border. When Lionpaw asks if he can come as well, his mentor tells him to go home and get some ointment on his scratches.
- When Lionpaw sleeps in, Hollypaw grunts at him, asking him if Ashfur had any jobs for him.
- Ashfur starts a training session by prompting Hollypaw and Lionpaw with what other Clans' strengths and weaknesses are. They both name them and Ashfur asks them some more questions in order to prepare them for battle training.
- Millie objects to changing her name during the warrior ceremony, which causes Ashfur to flick his tail irritably, showing that he disagreed with Firestar's decision to oblige her.
- Hollypaw, Leafpool, and Jaypaw come to Cinderpaw's aid after she falls out of the Sky Oak. Spiderleg disappears and Ashfur appears in his place, making this most likely to be a consistency error. Despite it originally supposed to be Spiderleg, Ashfur helps carry Cinderpaw back to camp.
- Ashfur gets angry with Lionpaw when he misses a vole. He becomes annoyed again during a training session when Lionpaw has trouble with a move, and leaves the young cat to learn the badger defense move, one of the hardest fighting techniques, on his own. After a while, Ashfur returns, and is surprised to see that Lionpaw has already mastered the move, even adding an extra kick at the end. Lionpaw claims to have made it up on his own, but in reality, Tigerstar had taught it to him. Ashfur is pleased with Lionpaw, and his apprentice gets back on his good side.
- Ashfur praises Lionpaw for the prey he caught that day, but he does not sound enthusiastic and Jaypaw notices something wrong that he can't quite detect.
- When Berrynose snarls at Lionpaw to keep his nose out of holes, Lionpaw retorts sharply. Ashfur calmly says it is enough, and that Berrynose isn't his mentor, but that Lionpaw doesn't have to stick his nose in everything.
- During a training session, Ashfur is seen watching Lionpaw defeat Berrynose. He shows neither approval or disapproval toward him. Ashfur assigns Lionpaw to help repair the elder's den. During another training session, Lionpaw accuses Ashfur of not being tough enough on him. Ashfur becomes very angry, and eventually, after Lionpaw challenges him, he and Lionpaw begin to fight brutally. It is not like other training sessions, because both Ashfur and Lionpaw have their teeth bared and claws unsheathed. They end up wounding each other, but not severely.
- After the fight, when both are back at camp, Ashfur praises Lionpaw, saying he will be as good as his father. Despite his comments, he lets the young apprentice have the first pick from the fresh-kill pile. However, Hollypaw thinks that Ashfur had pushed Lionpaw too hard.
- When Night and Talon come to seek help from the Clan, Ashfur says that they can easily spare a few warriors to help the Tribe. He also says that they should, since the Tribe helped a lot on the Great Journey.
- Ashfur calls Lionpaw out for a hunting patrol after Lionpaw gets back from the mountains. Lionpaw wonders if Ashfur would be angry with him for sleeping in late. When Lionpaw takes longer, Ashfur calls him out again, with sharpness in his voice. Ashfur greets Lionpaw when he comes out of the apprentices' den and mentions that Icepaw and Whitewing were waiting to go out hunting. While out in the forest, Ashfur advises Icepaw to keep her tail still while in the hunter's crouch and Lionpaw looks at him in surprise, thinking that the warrior didn't care about apprentices. Ashfur shares a glance with Lionpaw and it's clear that he wanted Lionpaw to point out Icepaw's mistake. Lionpaw is angered at Ashfur for expecting him to mentor another apprentice.
- On their hunt, Whitewing asks Ashfur if they should go down to the lake, but he doesn't reply. Lionpaw wonders why he isn't responding. Ashfur silences Lionpaw with his tail when he tries to give advice to Whitewing and then tells Whitewing to trust her instinct. Ashfur explains to Lionpaw that Whitewing needs to build her confidence on her own. Ashfur later congratulates Icepaw when she catches a vole.
- When the patrol is heading back to camp, Lionpaw talks with Icepaw and she mentions that Ashfur is a great mentor. Lionpaw watches Ashfur walking ahead and recalls how Ashfur had taught him well, but that Tigerstar was his other mentor. The patrol arrives back at the camp and deposits their prey.
- When WindClan invades the ThunderClan camp, Ashfur is seen calling Lionpaw over from the elders' den. He tells Lionpaw to help Mousefur and Longtail up to the Highledge while Ashfur helps Whitewing and Icepaw fight off some WindClan cats. Ashfur is seen with Whitewing and Icepaw pushing WindClan back.
- Firestar later sends Ashfur out with Lionpaw, Dustpelt, Birchfall, and Cloudtail to make sure WindClan has left the territory. Ashfur's pelt bristles angrily when the patrol learns that none of the WindClan cats had gone back over the border. The patrol heads back to the camp and explains everything to Firestar. Later, Ashfur is sent with a patrol to defend ThunderClan territory, along with Firestar, Lionpaw, Berrynose, Spiderleg, and Poppyfrost. When the patrol finds the underground tunnel which WindClan had used to get over to ThunderClan territory, Ashfur is very angry about it and helps cover it up with dirt.
- In the battle, Ashfur is seen sticky with blood as he stands next to Berrynose. He encourages Spiderleg to get up so that he can go back to the camp and be treated by Leafpool. Back in the camp, Ashfur alerts Firestar that more cats are coming from WindClan's direction. During the battle, Ashfur is seen battling with a brown tabby tom.
- After the battle, Lionpaw notices that Ashfur still hadn't washed the blood off his paws. Ashfur talks with some other warriors about why the sun might have vanished.
- Ashfur is seen talking with Dustpelt and they are comparing the battle with BloodClan to the recent battle. Ashfur comments that Lionpaw is ready to become a warrior and he glances over at his apprentice. Ashfur then calls Lionpaw over for a patrol with Sorreltail and Whitewing.
- Ashfur congratulates Lionpaw after Firestar announces that he will be made a warrior. His apprentice is then granted his warrior name, Lionblaze.
- Lionblaze wants Ashfur to prepare him for fighting in the future, so he begs Ashfur to help him. Ashfur reluctantly agrees, and they go out to the training hollow. While fighting, it seems that the two cats are equally matched as both do not give up. Suddenly, Ashfur unsheathes his claws and Lionblaze follows. They start fighting, really wounding each other. Firestar sees this and screeches at them to stop immediately. They stop and Firestar says he is ashamed to see two warriors fighting with claws unsheathed in their own territory. Lionblaze is quick to take the blame, but Firestar says that since Ashfur is a senior warrior, he should have more sense than to have listened to his former apprentice. Hollyleaf is not happy at the way they were fighting, as if in a real battle.
- When Tawnypelt and her kits, Flamepaw, Tigerpaw, and Dawnpaw, comes to seek refuge in ThunderClan, Ashfur asks if she is okay, hostility in his question. Tawnypelt cautiously replies that she is fine and that prey is running well in ShadowClan. When Firestar assures that she will have a place in ThunderClan, Ashfur asks if she can be trusted, especially while patrolling the ShadowClan border.
- A large fire starts near the ThunderClan camp, and all the ThunderClan cats are forced to flee. Ashfur sees Squirrelflight pushing a fallen branch through the fire to Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf, who are trapped on the other side. Ashfur helps her push it toward them, but puts one paw on the end, confusing Squirrelflight and her kits. He tells Squirrelflight that he is furious and heartbroken that Squirrelflight chose Brambleclaw instead of him. He says that he conspired with Hawkfrost of RiverClan to kill Firestar, revealing he was the traitor within ThunderClan that Hawkfrost spoke of before he died. He says that he has never hated Brambleclaw, and that he has always blamed Squirrelflight. Ashfur tells Squirrelflight that, since he could not kill Firestar, he will kill her kits, so she would feel the same pain he felt. To save their lives, Squirrelflight tells Ashfur that they aren't really their kits. Ashfur is alarmed, and finally, he lets Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf go, but he vows to tell the Clans the secret at a Gathering.
- Armed with Squirrelflight's news, Ashfur plans to let it be known at the next Gathering. He asks Firestar if he can go to the Gathering. Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, Squirrelflight, and Lionblaze all beg him not to, but he pays them no heed. Jayfeather even visits Ashfur in a dream, but the tom refuses to back down, even though the medicine cat apprentice noticeably spooks him, even in the waking world.
- On the night of the Gathering, Ashfur disappears. Firestar mentions that he had asked specifically to come to this Gathering. The Clan decides to go on without him. When they reach the WindClan border, they find Ashfur's body in the stream, dead.
- Leafpool is said to have been anguished as she cares for Ashfur's body. Jayfeather wonders in alarm if Leafpool had loved Ashfur, but he shakes the idea away.
- Leafpool discovers that Ashfur hadn't drowned as was previously thought, but was murdered because of the teeth marks in his throat. Due to the absence of other Clan's scents, it is believed that a ThunderClan cat was responsible for his death, though some still thought it might have been a WindClan cat, but that their scent might have been washed away.
- As moonlight washes over the stone hollow, Leafpool crouches over Ashfur's body. The pale light turns the dead cat's body to silver as she grooms him for burial. Jayfeather is beside Leafpool, smoothing out Ashfur's pelt and fluffing it up as it dries. Leafpool yowls the ancient words a medicine cat says to a deceased Clanmate. She doesn't feel comfortable saying the words, promising a new life for Ashfur. She feels hurt and remembers how she discovered the teeth marks in his neck, and concluding only a cat could kill him. She wonders which cat hated Ashfur so much that they murdered him in cold blood, leaving no signs of struggle. Leafpool wonders if a WindClan cat or a passing rogue could have killed him, but she is chilled to her bones thinking a ThunderClan cat murdered him. Ashfur had been outspoken and strong-willed, but a loyal and respected warrior as well, and she thinks about why any ThunderClan cat wanted him dead.
- Bending over Ashfur again, Leafpool begins to clean his paw pads when something soft and light touches her muzzle. She draws back to find a tuft of fur snagged in Ashfur's claws, which is later revealed to belong to Hollyleaf. She suddenly yells this can't be true, and she knows that scent. Leafpool desperately tries to convince herself it was just one of the warriors carrying Ashfur's body back to camp, but the smell of water is too strong to have come from a cat with dry fur, and Ashfur's claws are soft and limp. The tuft of fur could only be from the gray warrior's murderer. Leafpool wraps the tuft of fur in a leaf and hides it in the cleft in the medicine den, and she tells herself the truth about Ashfur's death must never come out.
- When Lionblaze finishes his fight with Tigerstar, he says that Ashfur is dead and Squirrelflight won't let the truth come out. After he wakes up, Lionblaze hears Thornclaw yowling that a WindClan cat must have killed Ashfur. Honeyfern disagrees and says that Firestar could be right and a ThunderClan cat could have killed him. Cloudtail argues that Firestar could be wrong. Ferncloud asks why any of them would kill Ashfur since he had no enemies. Lionblaze remembers the night of the fire, when Ashfur blocked the branch that would save him, Jayfeather, and Hollyleaf, and how Squirrelflight revealed they weren't their kits so she could protect them. However, she had given Ashfur a weapon more powerful than a flaming branch. Lionblaze knew Ashfur would tell the truth about them at the Gathering, only his death had sealed his jaws forever.
- Spiderleg breaks the golden warrior's thoughts and asks if Ashfur quarreled with any particular WindClan cat since Lionblaze was Ashfur's apprentice. He quickly says no. He couldn't lie and say Ashfur quarreled with a WindClan cat, but he wishes it were true. Lionblaze adds that he didn't see Ashfur that much before his death. Brackenfur says that any cat could have quarreled with the gray tom. Sorreltail agrees with her mate and is about to say they can't be sure until Spiderleg interrupts her, and explains Ashfur was found in the WindClan border stream. Sorreltail faces Spiderleg and says she wants more evidence before she blames any cat. Honeyfern and Brackenfur agree, but Lionblaze sees most of the cats think a WindClan warrior murdered Ashfur.
- When Berrynose and Thornclaw rally the cats to raid WindClan, Brambleclaw interrupts them. Spiderleg says they're raiding WindClan because one of their warriors killed Ashfur. Brambleclaw angrily says there will be no raid on WindClan because they have no proof a WindClan cat killed him. Lionblaze thinks about all the times Brambleclaw had given him advice and played with him and his siblings when they were kits, and if he knew the truth that he wasn't the father of him, Jayfeather and Hollyleaf. Squirrelflight had told Ashfur Brambleclaw didn't know, and maybe the dark brown tom was lying and doing a good job of it. He beckons Lionblaze over and asks if he's alright, considering Ashfur was his mentor. Later, Leafpool reveals she knew that it was Hollyleaf who killed Ashfur, because the tuft of fur had her scent. When Hollyleaf is threatening to kill Leafpool with deathberries, Hollyleaf even confesses to killing Ashfur, telling Leafpool that he had to die because he was going to exploit the truth of Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather's birth towards the Clans.
- Firestar asks Leafpool if she could meet Ashfur in StarClan. He wants her to ask him who the cat is that is responsible for his death, but she refuses because she can't choose who to meet in StarClan. Later, Hollyleaf reveals at a Gathering that Leafpool and Crowfeather were her, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather's parents, not Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw. This is ironic because Hollyleaf had killed Ashfur so their secret wouldn't be revealed. Near the end of the book, Jayfeather sees a vision of Hollyleaf killing Ashfur. Hollyleaf later tells Lionblaze and Jayfeather that she killed Ashfur, and then she vanishes into the tunnels, which collapse afterward.
In the Omen of the Stars arc
- While Lionblaze and Cinderheart are out on a run, they come across the collapsed tunnels, where Hollyleaf was supposedly killed. Lionblaze remembers in detail the true story of Ashfur's death, and how Hollyleaf had murdered him in order to keep her parentage a secret. He also remembers how the Clans assumed the cause of Ashfur's untimely demise was a passing rogue.
- When Yellowfang is with Jayfeather in StarClan, the young medicine cat sees Ashfur running through the trees, and he stops and stares back at Jayfeather with burning eyes. Then after a while, Ashfur leaps away into some bushes. Jayfeather is surprised that Ashfur is there, and he yowls in alarm. However, Yellowfang simply says that all he did wrong was love too much. Jayfeather snorts that the gray tom tried to throw him off a cliff. Yellowfang retorts that he didn't and that Squirrelflight stopped him. She also mentions that maybe all Squirrelflight did wrong was love too much as well. Jayfeather is confused by Yellowfang's statement, but she snorts at him to work it out for himself and that she doesn't have all day to talk.
- When Hollyleaf comes back to the Clans, Jayfeather decides to visit Ashfur in StarClan. He sneaks up on him, creeping closer when suddenly Bluestar jumps down and tells him that it's not a very good idea. She tells him that he won't learn anything from talking to Ashfur. He knows who killed him, and why, and maybe he did a lot to bring it on himself. Jayfeather tries to argue, but Bluestar continues, saying that if Ashfur found his way to StarClan, he must belong there, and asserts that is what they all have to believe. Both Ashfur and Hollyleaf paid a high price for what they did wrong, and perhaps justice is now served.
- When the Clan questions Hollyleaf about her disappearance and her possible involvement in Ashfur's death, Hollyleaf admits that she was present for and the cause of her Clanmate's demise, though Brambleclaw interrupts and tells the Clan that he was also present, and that Ashfur had attacked Hollyleaf and died when he slipped and fell in the stream. The Clan is appalled and surprised that their former Clanmate would do such a thing and accepts Hollyleaf fully back into its ranks.
- Ashfur is mentioned very briefly by Hollyleaf when the she-cat explains to Lionblaze that she cannot be the fourth cat in the prophecy because of the murder she committed.
In the A Vision of Shadows arc
- Ashfur is briefly mentioned by Jayfeather, when he tells Alderheart about the consequences of taking a mate while being a medicine cat. He explains Leafpool's story to Alderheart, saying that the truth about his own, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf's parantage is what broke Hollyleaf, resulting in her killing Ashfur.
In the Field Guides
- Rock tells the kits that it is a shame that Ashfur is most famous for quarreling with Brambleclaw over Squirrelflight's affection, because he was a good cat. He was able to see past Squirrelflight's fiery exterior and love her while Brambleclaw still saw her as a nuisance, but that Ashfur protected her too much, and tried to stifle her courageous, daring spirit, which is not what she needed in a mate. But despite his troubles with Squirrelflight, he was a brave and loyal warrior.
- He also mentored Lionpaw very well, and despite his somewhat confrontational nature, he was a loyal warrior of ThunderClan. Rock says not to listen to Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight too much, as they dismiss him as somewhat of a troublemaker, since Ashfur has a story of his own.
- Ashfur only appears when Tigerstar is introducing ThunderClan's forest camp to the reader. He states that Ashfur and his sister Ferncloud lured the dogs out of the camp first, due to the fact that their mother, Brindleface, had been fed to the dogs as prey. Sandstorm later took over from Ashfur and Ferncloud, and ran the dogs to the gorge.
- Ashfur is mentioned very briefly on Squirrelflight's page to have fallen in love with her, and despite his potential of loyalty, he did not appreciate the strength underneath her impulsiveness, as well as his death having to do with her depression later on.
- His own profile is featured. Ashfur had loved Squirrelflight, and was hurt that she chose Brambleclaw. Because of this, he put her kits in danger until Squirrelflight revealed they were not hers. He planned to tell the Clans at the next Gathering about this. Hollyleaf, not wanting to risk her parentage being revealed, killed him to keep it a secret. Despite his intentions, he was a great warrior and mentor to Lionblaze due to the training he gave him, and was very loyal to his Clan. If Squirrelflight had returned his affections, he may have risen to high ranks; his rivalry with Brambleclaw and love for Squirrelflight interfered with this.
- On Hollyleaf's page, it is told that Ashfur's death had been an accident because of Hollyleaf's desperation to keep him from telling the Clans about her true heritage. She did not see a reason to tell Firestar what she had done. He is also mentioned on Hawkfrost's page, where it is said that he had been the ThunderClan cat to take part in Hawkfrost's plan to kill Firestar with the fox trap, though Ashfur had not known the RiverClan warrior's true intentions. He is mentioned a couple times on Sol's page. When Ashfur was killed under mysterious circumstances, many ThunderClan cats believed it was Sol. They found Sol, and he was taken back as prisoner and accused as Ashfur's murderer.
In the Novellas
- Leafpool sees Squirrelflight sharing a mouse with Brambleclaw, and she realizes that her sister has chosen Brambleclaw over Ashfur as a mate.
- He is later mentioned when Brackenfur calls to him to take out their apprentices, Whitepaw and Birchpaw.
- A storm occurs at the lake, and lightning strikes a tree in the ThunderClan camp, causing fire to catch and spread around in the hollow. Ashfur is threatening to kill Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather, but Squirrelflight makes an attempt to defend them. It is noted that Ashfur is trying to kill the three cats due to Squirrelflight taking Brambleclaw as a mate instead of him. As a result, Ashfur holds a grudge against Squirrelflight's family. In order to protect the three cats from him, Squirrelflight reveals a secret that shocks them all: Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather are not her kits.
- Later, when Hollyleaf flees into the tunnels, she thinks about how she killed Ashfur, and that her littermates and Leafpool know about the murder.
- In the family tree on the official Warriors site, it states that Whitestorm is the mate to Brindleface, and father to Ashfur and Ferncloud. This tree was however confirmed not to be canon, and therefore it's unconfirmed whether he truly has any relation to them.
- Kate thinks that Ashfur forgave Hollyleaf for killing him once she joined StarClan. This is contradicted by Vicky, who says they probably never forgave each other and avoid each other in StarClan.
- When asked about Ashfur's residence on her Facebook page, Vicky said the following: "[He] went to StarClan because he was essentially a loyal and well-meaning warrior. He was just driven a bit crazy from unrequited love!", and also replied that she'd been thinking for a long while about where to send him, and considered the Dark Forest.
- Vicky believes that Ashfur won't turn up in the future.
- Vicky believes that Ashfur wasn't chosen as the cat who loved Squirrelflight for any specific reason.
- Either he or his sister, Ferncloud, were called tawny.
- He was mistakenly said to have a dark pelt.
Please do not edit this gallery
Please do not edit this gallery
- Sandstorm: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Sorreltail: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Shrewpaw: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Spiderleg: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Birchfall: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Foxleap: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Hollykit: Status unknown
- Larchkit: Status unknown
- Icecloud: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Rosepetal: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Ivypool: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Dovewing: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Lightkit: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Pouncekit: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Thriftkit: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Bristlekit: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Lionblaze: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Jayfeather: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Alderheart: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Juniperkit: Deceased, residence unknown
- Hollyleaf: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Sparkpelt: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Dandelionkit: Deceased, residence unknown
- Cinderpelt Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Brightheart Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Thornclaw Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Brackenfur: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Honeyfern: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Poppyfrost: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Cinderheart: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Molepaw: Status unknown
- Lilyheart: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Seedpaw: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Molewhisker: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Cherryfall: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Whitewing: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Ambermoon: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Dewnose: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Snowbush: Deceased, verified StarClan member
- Dovewing: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Ivypool: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Leafshade: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Honeyfur: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Larksong: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Eaglepaw: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Plumpaw: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Shellpaw: Living (As of The Raging Storm)
- Stempaw Living (As of The Raging Storm)
= Gender Unknown
= Gender Unknown
- Fernpaw: "Fireheart, we want to help."
- Fireheart: "I said warriors."
- A Dangerous Path, page 291
- "Pure blood is no guarantee of virtue!"
- —Ashfur getting angry The Sight, page 335
- Ashfur: "Was that the best you could do?"
- Lionpaw: "It's not my fault you taught me all the wrong moves!"
- Dark River, page 168
- "She could still see in her mind the blaze of rage in Ashfur's eyes, as if he'd forgotten he was fighting his own apprentice."
- —Narrator describing Hollypaw's thoughts after watching Lionpaw and Ashfur fight Outcast, page 82
- Squirrelflight: "Your quarrel with Brambleclaw has to stop. Too many moons have passed. You have to accept that I'm Brambleclaw's mate, not yours. You can't keep trying to punish Brambleclaw for something that was always meant to be."
- Ashfur: "I have no quarrel with Brambleclaw. I couldn't care less about Brambleclaw. It's not his fault he fell for a faithless she-cat. I know you think I've never forgiven Brambleclaw for stealing you from me, but you're wrong, and so is every cat that thinks so. My quarrel is with you, Squirrelflight. It always has been."
- Long Shadows, pages 272-273
- "Upset? I'm not upset. You have no idea how much pain I'm in. It's like being cut open every day, bleeding onto the stones. I can't understand how any of you failed to see the blood..."
- —Ashfur to Squirrelflight Long Shadows, page 273
- "Stay there! I can't believe you didn't know how much you hurt me. You are the blind one, not Jayfeather. Who do you think sent Firestar the message to go down to the lake, where the fox trap was? I wanted him to die, to take your father away so you'd know the real meaning of pain."
- —Ashfur to Squirrelflight Long Shadows, page 274
- Jayfeather: "Ashfur! He's here?"
- Yellowfang: "Why not? His only fault was to love too much."
- Sign of the Moon, page 94
|Ashpaw's apprentice ceremony|
References and citations
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Revealed in Sign of the Moon, pages 93-94
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Revealed in Rising Storm, allegiances
- ↑ Revealed in The Darkest Hour, page 210
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Revealed in Rising Storm, pages 41-42
- ↑ Revealed in Long Shadows, page 305
- ↑ Revealed in Sunrise, page 313
- ↑ Revealed in Rising Storm, page 41
- ↑ Revealed in Firestar's Quest, allegiances
- ↑ Revealed in Long Shadows, page 75
- ↑ Revealed in Twilight, page 113
- ↑ Revealed in The Sight, page 87
- ↑ Revealed in Fire and Ice, page 235
- ↑ Revealed in Sunrise, page 203
- ↑ Revealed in Sunset, page 49
- ↑ Revealed on the official Warriors site
- ↑ Revealed in Erin Hunter Chat 4
- ↑ Revealed on Kate's Facebook Page
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook
- ↑ Revealed in Forest of Secrets, page 225
- ↑ Revealed in Eclipse, page 218
- ↑ 24.0 24.1 24.2 24.3 24.4 Revealed on the Warriors website family tree
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 25.2 Revealed on Vicky's Facebook page
- ↑ 26.0 26.1 26.2 Revealed in Firestar's Quest, page 120
- ↑ Revealed in Fire and Ice, page 228
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook Page
- ↑ 29.0 29.1 Revealed in Bluestar's Prophecy, page 329
- ↑ Revealed on Vicky's Facebook page
- ↑ 31.0 31.1 Revealed in Rising Storm, page 42
- ↑ 32.0 32.1 32.2 Revealed in Midnight, page 84
- ↑ 33.0 33.1 33.2 33.3 33.4 Revealed in The Sight, page 5
- ↑ 34.0 34.1 34.2 Revealed in Firestar's Quest, page 509
- ↑ 35.0 35.1 Revealed in Outcast, page 8
- ↑ 36.0 36.1 36.2 36.3 Revealed in Sunrise, page 317
- ↑ 37.0 37.1 37.2 Revealed in Tigerheart's Shadow, chapter 18
- ↑ 38.0 38.1 38.2 Revealed in River of Fire, page 203
- ↑ 39.0 39.1 39.2 39.3 Revealed in The Apprentice's Quest, chapter 1
- ↑ Revealed in Bramblestar's Storm, page 478
- ↑ Revealed in Bramblestar's Storm manga, page 1
- ↑ Revealed in Bramblestar's Storm manga, page 2
- ↑ 43.0 43.1 Revealed in Fire and Ice, pages 95-97
- ↑ 44.0 44.1 Revealed in Forest of Secrets, pages 62-63
- ↑ 45.0 45.1 45.2 45.3 Revealed in Sunset, page 27
- ↑ 46.0 46.1 Revealed in The Forgotten Warrior, page 146
- ↑ 47.0 47.1 Revealed in The Fourth Apprentice, page 299
- ↑ 48.0 48.1 48.2 Revealed in The Last Hope, page 216
- ↑ 49.0 49.1 49.2 Revealed in The Apprentice's Quest, allegiances
- ↑ 50.0 50.1 50.2 50.3 Revealed in Shattered Sky, page 47