|"Fallowstar is fine. We are the cats who would have been."|
|— Smallstar to Graywing in Code of the Clans, page 115|
In Code of the Clans, when Graywing witnesses three WindClan kits fall to their death and does nothing to help, she later dreams that they visit her as what they would have been if they didn't die—Smallstar, Runningstorm, and Wolfheart. Graywing asks Smallstar if they had come to speak to her about Fallowstar, though they tell her that Fallowstar was fine.
- Code of the Clans (First appearance; mentioned only)