History needs to be completed
Wordings thus far are somewhat un-encyclopedic, improve
Is the content under Into the Wild supposed to be under Fire and Ice? I can never remember...
- Wait when was he an elder? I don't remember that.
Wasn't he ever seen as a warrior??
I thought he was?Dawny 18:33, June 23, 2010 (UTC)
No. He was an elder when he was made deputy, despite how old he was. I thought he was a warrios as well, but in one of the books it states that Nightstar was an elder when he was made leader, as well as CInderfur when he was made deputy.Cinderfur was a very minor cat in the series, I don't think anyone really cares anyways. - User:Gingertail/Sig 14:31, November 5, 2010 (UTC)
Cinderfur didn't make an actual appearance until after Nightstar made him deputy, so technically, he never appeared in the books as a warrior or an elder, only deputy. -Hollydapple798- 21:38, January 3, 2012 (UTC)
In rising storm it is said he died, did he do anything wrong to go to the dark forest. So why does he not have a starclan pixle. (smallearstorm)...7:44 october,21,2013
- Because we have not seen him post-death. If we see him, and he's in StarClan, then we'll give him an image. But, since we haven't seen him, he can't get one. —Jayce ( 05:05, 10/22/2013 )
He's in starclan he needs a starclan model
Isn't he dead he needs a starclan model