Talk:One-eye

Project Characters One-eye is a part of Project Characters It has been graded (silver)	Project Charart One-eye is a part of Project Charart It has been graded (silver)

Style Concerns

Current:

• All history needs major expansion.
• Needs a few quotes.

Older:

• Intro seems to have a POV that is not neutral about the characterEu^{(Talk!Contribs)} 15:52, 26 April 2008 (UTC)
• Template - Name titles need to be followed by a colonEulalia459678^{(Salamandastron)} 17:14, 30 November 2007 (UTC)
• Template - Family titles need to be followed by a colonEulalia459678^{(Salamandastron)} 17:14, 30 November 2007 (UTC)
• History needs to be completed
• Categories need to be added

One-eye's family

One-eye is the mate of Halftail and the mother of Runningwind and Mousefur, so they need to be put in the family sections. It is says so on the warriors website,

--Rocktalon 11:11, 24 December 2008 (UTC)

Rocktalon, we have said many times (and even the Erins have said) that those family trees are false and were created by a fan. FxC 12:04, 24 December 2008 (UTC)

Yes. See Canon.––Σulãlíã⁴⁵⁹ ₆₇₈ 19:57, 24 December 2008 (UTC)

she was also hurt by a badger by a badger clawing one of her eye out

It's true. It says so in Bluestar's Prophecy. Jaypaw189 20:58, 30 July 2009 (UTC) aka Jayie

That is true. But now im confused because in Into the Wild, Rusty described her as having a clouded, sightless eye.Emberstarfireclan 08:54, October 3, 2010 (UTC)

yeah, it was, but it fell off when she aged more. Graystripe448

Smallear?

This seems to be a timeline problem. One-eye is older than Smallear, but on Allegiances Bluestar's Prophecy and even on the browse inside, it says that she is an apprentice while he is a warrior. Also, Smallear is shown as the mentor of a Whitepaw one of whose eyes is clouded ans sightless, and who later becomes White-eye.––Σ ãliãs G.r.paw 11:07, 24 July 2009 (UTC)

Firepaw was younger than Sandpaw and Dustpaw, and he became a warrior before them... Forestpaw

Liar, i just read the book. it never says HOW she loses an eye -Snowstorm

Both Smallear and Sparrowpelt ( Half tail) are older then her. Unless she was an apprentice for a long time, injured like Sorreltail, with those two becoming a warrior before her. Erin hunter needs to clear that up, one of the three hunters at least

Acually, in the allegiances, it says that Smallear is "The oldest tom in ThunderClan"--Nightfall101 03:21, November 1, 2009 (UTC)

Yeah, she could be the oldest she-cat in ThunderClan.--Mousetalon 00:40, November 18, 2009 (UTC)

It actually says that she is the oldest cat in ThunderClan, here:

Smallear- gray tom with very small ears, the oldest tom in ThunderClan

One-eye- pale gray she-cat; the oldest cat in ThunderClan; virtually blind and deaf

I got this from Forest of Secrets in the allegiances --Dappleclaw 7:15 January 13, 2010

Mousefur, Runningwind, and Halftail

Guys! It was never confirmed that Halftail's her mate and Mousefur and Runningwind are their kits! As has been said many, many other times: quit relying on the family tree on the website. The Erins have clearly stated that it's not true. Sorry if I sound bossy...  Jane Volturi  ^(talk!) 01:33, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

It is in Bluestar's prophecy. Boltstar 02:26, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

I didn't know because I don't have BSP.  Jane Volturi  ^(talk!) 02:27, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

One-eye is the oldest

One-eyes eye was clawed out by a badger when she was an apprintice as it states in Code of the Clans. THis may not be true but my theory is that she and Smallear trained together but whne she was attacked she was forced into rehab in the mdicine cats den. Remember what happened to Brightheart? Almost the same situations and Brightheart was in the medicine cats den for a while. Meanwhile, Smallear becomes a warrior and so she is older then him but because of her injury it may seem like she's not. Artimas Hunter 22:59, December 22, 2009 (UTC)Artimas Hunter

Good theory! That even happened to Sorreltail, she was injured by a monster and her brothers were made warriors while she was healing. Dappleclaw 02:02, January 22, 2010 (UTC)Dappleclaw

Isn't Dappletail One-eye's sister? I think this may be true because they're listed as apprentices together in Bluestar's Prophecy and they always seem to be together.

Yeah, them being sisters make sense. But One-eye being the oldest and the whole Smallear thing actually doesn't work. Remember Speckletail in BP? Mossy ♫ ^{go away.} 19:06, September 26, 2010 (UTC)

Please stop discussing theories on talk pages. Take this kind of stuff to the forums. WhiteStorm is back! 19:29, September 26, 2010 (UTC)

I'm almost certain your right, Artimas!Emberstarfireclan 09:01, October 3, 2010 (UTC)

Stop discussing theories on the talk pages. This has already been said once. WhiteStorm is back! 17:29, October 3, 2010 (UTC)

Sorry Whitestorm I just want to say one thing. There is a book like I think code of the clans it says dappletail and her sister white-eye or vis versa went to the river because white-eye wanted to try fish they both got caught by the riverclan leader and their own leader the leaders made them try the fish and neither one of them liked but anyway in the book I think it says that they were sisters so that would make it white-eye and dappletail are the oldest she-cats in thunderclan 208.126.192.81 22:11, March 20, 2011 (UTC)Silverthistle

Badger?

Hey, guys. I have BP right in front of me, and I noticed on the page it said she lost her eye completely to a badger? I checked the ref for that, page 507, and I'm not seeing it. It says Halftail lost his tail to a badger, but it only states that White-eye took the new name One-eye. Here's the complete paragraph:

On the far side of the clearing, Spottedlaf emerged from the fern tunnel. She was the Clan's only medicine cat since Featherwhisker had died, killed by the same bout of greencough that had taken one of Bluestar's lives. But Featherwhisher had trained his apprentice well, and Spottedleaf was passionate about the welfare of her Clanmates. She'd cared for White-eye after she'd lost her blind eye completely, taking the new name One-eye. Her hearing was as poor as her sight these days.

One-eye wasn't the only warrior to have changed her name. Sparrowpelt had become Halftail when he'd lost the end of his tail to a badger. Now unable to balance properly, he'd moved to the elder's den, too, and left the tree climbing to his Clanmates.

Perhaps the person writing this could have been confused? It never mentions her losing her eye to a badger. GMF160^LionxDove 17:12, March 23, 2011 (UTC)