Did any of the Erins ever say that a cat has a grey pelt with a ROSE tail? I don't just "disagree with it", it is scientifically illogical. Cats do not just have rose tails.
Um, yes actually. It was cited as canon in Spottedleaf's Heart allegiances. So what if it's "scientifically illogical?" So are talking cats. This series itself is illogical. Hauntdapple☠️ It's spooky time ☠️ 14:44, 5/04/2017
Its a fantasy Fashion. Its suppose to be illogical. — Minkclaw 16:39, May 4, 2017 (UTC)
This series has never followed genetic possibility. So, in this universe, a gray cat with a red tail is possible, apparently. We have a confirmation from a book, so we have to keep it that way. dan 01:06, 11/06/2017